A cast for most waist breaks that have barely movedStrong evidence
The UK SWIFFT trial (31 hospitals, 439 adults with a clear break across the waist that had moved 2 mm or less) compared early surgery with a cast. These are the trial's reported results. Wrist pain and function at a year scored 11.9 after surgery and 14.0 after a cast, on a 0 to 100 scale where lower is better; the difference of 2.1 points was well below the 6 that would matter. Potentially serious complications from surgery affected 14% of the surgery group against 1% of the cast group, while cast problems affected 2% against 18%. Surgery cost about £1,300 more per person.
The strategy that worked was a below-elbow cast for 6 to 10 weeks, a check that the bone was joining, and an operation straight away if it wasn't: 17 of the 220 people in the cast group (8%) had surgery for a confirmed non-union (a bone that hadn't joined), 14 of them within 6 months. At 5 years (344 people), there was still no difference (0.6 points), grip and movement were similar, and among those scanned the bone hadn't joined in 2.1% after surgery and 3.3% after a cast. A meta-analysis of 7 trials agreed, with more, and more serious, complications after surgery, and UK hand surgery standards follow these results.
Sources 4, 9, 10, 11, 2
The thumb can stay out of the castStrong evidence
In a trial of 392 fractures, a cast that left the thumb free healed as well as one that included it. In 62 fractures confirmed on a scan, more of the break had bridged on a CT scan at 10 weeks with the thumb free (85% against 70%), with no difference in movement, grip or pain. A 2025 review agreed, and the UK standard is a below-elbow cast with the thumb free.
Sources 12, 13, 14, 2
A normal first X-ray doesn't rule it out, but most suspected breaks turn out fineStrong evidence
In a review, about 1 in 4 adults with a suggestive injury and a normal first X-ray turned out to have a fracture on later scans. No single examination finding confirms one, but no tenderness in the snuffbox makes one much less likely. In 223 people with a suspected fracture, 28% had one, and none of the 72 who had no snuffbox pain when the wrist was tipped towards the little finger, within 72 hours of the injury, had a fracture.
The National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE) suggests MRI as the first scan after a thorough examination, and UK hand surgeons expect a definite plan within 2 weeks. Most suspected fractures turn out fine: in 1,739 people in one Scottish health board, 0.35% needed an operation, and of 221 people looked after through a virtual clinic, 86% were discharged with advice and none had a troublesome non-union a year later.
Sources 3, 15, 16, 2, 17, 18
Breaks nearer the forearm heal less reliablyStrong evidence
The scaphoid's blood supply enters at the thumb end and runs back towards the forearm, so a break can cut off the supply to the end nearer the forearm (avascular necrosis), and breaks there heal slowly. In a review of 1,147 fractures treated without surgery, 34% of breaks at the forearm end didn't join, 7.5 times the risk of breaks further down. UK standards fix those breaks if they have moved at all.
A scaphoid that is left unjoined usually leads to wrist arthritis: in 278 people with one, 62% had arthritis, and for waist breaks nearer the forearm, half had it within about 2 years. Some arthritis on scans is common even after healing: 5 years after SWIFFT, 52% of those scanned had some, equally after a cast or surgery, and only the more severe arthritis went with worse pain and function. Breaks with at least a fifth bridged at a year went on to heal without more treatment.
Sources 1, 19, 2, 20, 21
Children's scaphoid fractures heal well in a castEmerging evidence
Across 17 studies (812 fractures), 93.5% of children's scaphoid fractures were treated in a cast; 96% healed, 99% got normal movement back and 97% were pain-free. In 91 children with symptoms but two normal X-rays, 5.5% turned out to have a fracture and none needed surgery. One NHS children's service rechecks at 10 to 14 days and, if a fracture is confirmed, uses a cast for 4 to 8 weeks.
Sources 22, 23, 24
The exercises are borrowed from wrist fracture programmesEmerging evidence
We found no trials of exercise after a scaphoid fracture. NHS leaflets agree on keeping the fingers, elbow and shoulder moving in the cast, aiming for a full fist within 1 to 2 weeks. After the cast, the stages here follow an NHS wrist fracture programme written for a different break: movement first, then held stretches, then weight through the hand, then strength, timed by your team. Treat the doses as starting points.
Sources 8, 7, 25, 26