What it is
Just above the ankle joint, the shin bone (tibia) and the outer leg bone (fibula) are held together by a group of ligaments called the syndesmosis: ligaments at the front and back, one between the bones, and a membrane running up the leg. They keep the socket of the ankle joint tight around the ankle bone. A high ankle sprain stretches or tears them, on its own or together with an outer ankle sprain, an injury to the strong ligament on the inner side (the deltoid), or a fracture. The National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE) calls these the most severe ligament injuries of the ankle.
Sources 1, 2, 3
How it happens, and who gets it
Usually the foot is planted and turned outwards while the leg turns in: a player rolled on from the side, or a kneeling player whose heel is struck. Less often, the ankle is bent up hard. NHS Lothian lists football, rugby, skiing and basketball, falls and accidents.
In US college sport, high ankle sprains were commonest in men's American football, then wrestling and ice hockey; 60% came from contact, and 47% kept players out for a week or more. In elite European football, isolated high ankle sprains were 7% of 1,320 ankle ligament injuries, and players missed 39 days on average.
Sources 1, 2, 4, 5, 6
How it's recognised
Pain and swelling above the ankle at the front, between the bones, sometimes spreading up the leg; bruising and stiffness; and pain pushing off or pivoting. Most people can't walk normally without crutches at first.
No single test is reliable. In 87 people with ankle sprains checked against MRI, tenderness over the ligament picked up 92% of high ankle sprains and being unable to hop 89%, but both were also common in other sprains. The squeeze test (squeezing the shin bones together mid-calf) and pain out of proportion to the injury were rarer in other sprains: 88% and 79% of people without a high ankle sprain tested negative. So clinicians combine several tests, and a review advised MRI before a final diagnosis.
Sources 4, 1, 7, 8
Ruling out a break, all the way up the leg
Clinicians check for a fracture first. The Ottawa ankle rules decide who needs an ankle X-ray, and our ankle sprain guide explains them. With a suspected high ankle sprain, they also feel the whole outer leg bone: a Maisonneuve fracture breaks it high up, near the knee, with the syndesmosis torn, from the same twisting injury. It hurts mostly at the ankle and very little at the break.
In 5 emergency patients, a Maisonneuve fracture was missed despite ankle X-rays, and all of them needed surgery; the authors' message is to feel the whole fibula in every ankle injury. These injuries range from stable to very unstable, often come with other ankle fractures, and usually need the syndesmosis fixed.
Sources 9, 10, 11
Stable or unstable
A European consensus of specialist societies (ESSKA-AFAS) sorts isolated high ankle sprains into stable and unstable. Stable ones are treated without surgery, and unstable ones, where the two bones spread apart, with surgery. Specialists check with tests that move the outer leg bone and with X-rays that measure the gap between the bones; NHS Lothian says a standing X-ray may be taken.
Some injuries look stable at rest and spread apart only under load. In 64 elite athletes, a positive squeeze test made instability 9.5 times as likely, and an injury to the inner (deltoid) ligament 11 times; those that looked unstable had keyhole surgery to check. Clear instability without a fracture is uncommon, so most high ankle sprains are treated without surgery, but a review notes that unstable ones are often overlooked.
Sources 12, 4, 13, 1, 14
Scans: what they show
MRI shows the syndesmosis ligaments well, and other damage such as outer ligament sprains, bone bruises and cartilage injuries. Some findings are common and don't predict recovery: in professional ice hockey players, bone bruises were seen in 71% of 21 scans, and no MRI pattern predicted the time lost. In the National Football League (NFL), the pattern did matter: injuries with a fracture took a median of 250 days, those with a complete deep deltoid tear or a widened joint 175, and the rest 27. A scan finding guides your team; it isn't a timetable.
Sources 1, 15, 3
How it usually goes
It takes longer than a common sprain: a median of 62 days to full recovery, against 15 for an outer ankle sprain, in 63 young athletes; 55 days against 28 for severe outer sprains in cadets; and 45 days on average in National Hockey League players. In one NFL team, players with high ankle sprains missed more games and practices than those with outer sprains. Every step and push-off loads the injured ligaments, and other structures are often hurt too: only 13% of 83 NFL injuries were isolated.
Most people get back: 96% of 901 elite athletes returned to sport, after about 58 days on average. But among 96 cadets' ankle sprains, a high ankle sprain was the strongest predictor of lingering symptoms 6 months later. In 9 of 10 cadets, bone formed in the healing ligament, without instability, stiffness or arthritis at about 20 months.
Sources 16, 17, 18, 15, 19, 3, 20, 21