Riding hats prevent serious head injuriesStrong evidence
In 20 matched pairs of injured riders, those without hats had about 9 times the odds of bleeding in or around the brain. In children, no hat went with 2.5 times the odds of a brain injury, and hats went with milder brain injuries and shorter hospital stays. A review found hats cut the absolute risk of head injury by 40% to 50%. One rural US series found hats reduced only surface injuries, a reminder that they can't prevent everything. These are observational studies, consistent across countries.
Sources 6, 57, 58, 59, 35, 60
Hats don't prevent all concussionsEmerging evidence
Of 139 head injuries in riders whose hats were returned after falls, 91% were concussions and 4% skull fractures, and 46% of the hats were undamaged, suggesting many are too stiff for the turf or sand they hit. Real concussive falls were angled, softer and longer impacts than the drops onto steel that certification tests use. In one survey, only 12% of riders knew that hats can't prevent concussion.
Sources 7, 61, 62, 63
Replace your hat after a fallEmerging evidence
In laboratory tests, the foam liner of jockey hats was compressed by 5% to 39% after one impact and by 33% to 70% after four, protecting less each time. The Pony Club says hats "must be replaced after a severe impact as subsequent protection will be significantly reduced". Yet 46% of riders in one survey had reused a hat after a hit to the head, and 78% of collegiate riders wouldn't replace one after every fall.
Sources 64, 65, 63, 66
MIPS hasn't been shown to reduce concussionMixed evidence
In 357 collegiate riders, head injuries were as common with hats with a Multi-directional Impact Protection System (MIPS) liner as without. In a laboratory fall onto sand, MIPS hats didn't reduce peak forces on the head, though the impact lasted a little less long. What matters is a hat to a current standard, well fitted and replaced after a fall.
Sources 66, 67
Body protectorsEmerging evidence
The British Equestrian Trade Association (BETA) says its Level 3 body protector "should prevent minor bruising that would have produced stiffness and pain, reduce soft tissue injuries and prevent a limited number of rib fractures". In US Pony Club incident reports, vests in cross-country went with 56% fewer injuries, but not on the flat or in show jumping. In 92 children who fell onto their trunk, vests weren't linked with fewer trunk injuries, in a study too small to be sure. A review found vests weren't linked with fewer spinal cord injuries, though they may protect the chest.
Sources 68, 69, 70, 71, 72
Air jacketsMixed evidence
Air jackets are worn over a Level 3 body protector for cross-country, as the rules require, not instead of one. They haven't been shown to reduce injuries. In 3,305 falls in international eventing, riders in air jackets had about 1.7 times the odds of a serious or fatal injury, an association that may reflect who wears them and how they ride; the researchers couldn't explain it. A review reached the same view. In British Eventing's 2022 falls, 47% of riders who fell wore one.
Sources 9, 73, 74, 75, 8
Stirrups and bootsMixed evidence
The Pony Club says it is "strongly recommended that the design of the stirrup chosen allows the foot to be released easily in the event of a rider fall", with stirrups about 7 mm wider than the boot on each side, and the Highway Code advises boots or shoes with hard soles and heels. A small series of children's feet crushed after staying in the stirrup supports this, but no trial of safety stirrups has been done.
Sources 76, 46, 77
Experience, instruction and the right horseEmerging evidence
A riding qualification and older age went with fewer injuries in Switzerland, qualified eventers were hurt less than novices, and a risk-taking attitude predicted injury. Riding many different horses went with more injuries, and Pony Club horses misbehaved more when competing, fat, on lush grass or rarely exercised. The Highway Code suggests the BHS Ride Safe Award for less experienced riders. Our suggestion: lessons with a qualified instructor and a horse that suits your level.
Sources 45, 5, 54, 55, 77
Eventing's fencesEmerging evidence
British Eventing made frangible pins, which let a rail drop when a horse hits it, compulsory on all suitable cross-country fences in 2006, to cut rotational falls in which the horse somersaults. Since 2002 to 2003, falls per jump have fallen by nearly a quarter, and the share of riders killed or seriously injured by 71%, alongside several other changes. In 2022, when a frangible part broke, none of the horses somersaulted.
Sources 78, 75
How riders landEmerging evidence
In 80 filmed race falls, jockeys who didn't tuck and roll had about 5 times the odds of a high-risk landing, and those who hung on to the reins about 7 times. In eventing falls, faster approaches and a horse that carried on going went with high-risk falls. Our suggestion: let go of the reins, tuck your chin and roll away from the horse. Fall training hasn't been tested.
Sources 79, 74
On the groundEmerging evidence
Kicks cause many of the worst injuries, including to the head, and the Kentucky trauma researchers and an Australian children's hospital both advise hats when handling horses as well as riding. Our suggestions: a hat when leading, lungeing or handling young or unfamiliar horses, boots, never kneeling or sitting by a horse's legs, and getting checked after any kick to the head, chest or tummy, even if you feel fine.
Sources 24, 59, 10
What isn't shownMixed evidence
Measures without good evidence in riding:
- Any hat that prevents concussion.
- Body protectors that prevent spinal injuries.
- Air jackets that reduce serious injuries.
- Safety stirrups, hi-vis and fall training: no trials.
- Fitness training that prevents falls: no trial; in a pilot study of 14 riders, lower fitness, but also more strength and power, went with falls.
Sources 7, 71, 9, 80