Limiting full contact in practiceEmerging evidence
Across studies, strategies that limited contact in practice went with about two-thirds fewer practice concussions. After Wisconsin's high-school rule limiting how much and how long players could hit in practice, practice concussions fell from 0.76 to 0.33 per 1,000 athlete-exposures, while game concussions didn't change. In one high school, a statewide limit cut head impacts by 42% a season, most in linemen.
As a 2022 review describes it, a high-school limit of 75 minutes of full contact a week in the season's second week, and 60 minutes from week 3, was followed by 54% fewer practice concussions. These are before-and-after studies, so other changes may have played a part.
Sources 3, 48, 49, 28
Coach education: Heads Up FootballEmerging evidence
USA Football's coaching course covers equipment fitting, tackling technique, drills with less player contact, and concussion, heat and cardiac emergencies, taught through a league's player safety coach. In 2,108 players aged 5 to 15, leagues using it together with Pop Warner's practice contact rules had about an eighth of the practice injuries of leagues using neither, and leagues using the course alone about a third; game injuries fell only where the practice rules were also in place.
In high schools, practice and game injuries were lower with a player safety coach, and concussions were 4.1 against 6.0 per 100 players with the course. None of these studies was randomised, and USA Football funded two of them. Nearly half of youth coaches missed the safety coach's clinic.
Sources 50, 51, 52, 53, 54
Tackling with the head upStrong evidence
Most neck fractures came from hits with the top of the helmet and the neck straight. Since 1976, US high-school and college rules ban spearing and tackling helmet-first, and permanent paralysis fell from 34 cases a year to 5. The National Athletic Trainers' Association (NATA) says keeping the head up and making contact with the shoulder or chest lowers the risk, that the rules are rarely enforced, and that coaches should spend more practice time on correct technique.
In 3,000 game tackles reviewed by Texas researchers, head-up tackles with the inside shoulder were the most successful, though most coaches who replied to their survey taught a riskier head-across technique. In a laboratory study in 24 young players, practising a head-up tackle cut hard head accelerations.
Sources 5, 6, 7, 55, 56
Kickoff rulesEmerging evidence
After the Ivy League, a group of US universities, moved the kickoff line forward 5 yards and the touchback line from the 25 to the 20-yard line in 2016, touchbacks rose from 18% to 48% of kickoffs and concussions on kickoffs fell from about 11 to 2 per 1,000 kickoff plays, in a before-and-after study.
Source 57
Lace-up ankle braces, as trialledStrong evidence
The one randomised trial of braces in football:
- Who: 2,081 high-school players in 50 Wisconsin schools, randomised by school for the 2010 season.
- What: a lace-up ankle brace on both ankles, individually fitted, for every conditioning session, practice and game.
- Effect: 61% fewer acute ankle injuries (0.48 against 1.12 per 1,000 exposures), in players with and without a previous sprain; about 28 players braced to prevent one injury. Injuries weren't less severe, and knee injuries didn't rise.
- Compliance: braces were worn in 44% of all exposures in the study, and the results were analysed by the group players were put in.
Source 58
Knee braces for healthy kneesMixed evidence
In 1,396 US military cadets playing tackle football, preventive knee braces cut knee injuries only in defensive players. In college players the trend was small and not clear, and across 6 studies the results were inconsistent, two finding more knee injuries in braces. They aren't recommended for uninjured knees.
Sources 59, 60, 61
Helmets and padded helmet coversEmerging evidence
Catastrophic head injuries have stayed low since modern helmets arrived in the early 1970s. But in 2,081 high-school players, concussion rates didn't differ by helmet brand, age or reconditioning. When the NFL made padded caps compulsory in practice for linemen, tight ends and linebackers, concussions in those positions fell, but not for impacts to the helmet shell, so the padding can't explain the fall on its own.
Sources 32, 62, 33
MouthguardsMixed evidence
Across sports, people without mouthguards had over twice the risk of mouth and face injuries. For concussion the evidence is mixed: across collision sports, wearers had about a quarter fewer concussions, but in high-school football, custom-fitted mouthguards went with more concussions than off-the-shelf ones, an association. Wear one for your teeth and jaw.
Sources 63, 3, 32
What isn't shownMixed evidence
Popular measures without good evidence in football:
- A warm-up programme: none has been tested in American football. The FIFA 11+, the warm-up from football's world governing body (FIFA), cut injuries in football (soccer), and strength training cut sports injuries in general.
- Neck strengthening to prevent concussion: the link between neck strength and concussion was small, not clear and very low certainty across team sports.
- State concussion laws and catastrophic brain injuries: serious structural brain injuries didn't fall after the laws came in, at about 1 per 100,000 players a year.
Sources 64, 65, 66, 34