Where it hurts, and when, points to the causeEmerging evidence
Tenderness spread along the inner edge of the shin is typical of shin splints: a scoping review found it described in 95% of the papers on them. One spot you can cover with a fingertip is a stress fracture until it has been checked.
Timing helps too. Shin splints hurt during and after running and ease over days; a stress fracture hurts with every step, then at rest and at night; exertional compartment syndrome builds at the same point in every run and fades within minutes of stopping; and narrowed arteries bring on a calf ache after a set walking distance that goes within minutes of standing still. Leg pain that eases when you sit or bend forward points to narrowing in the spine (spinal stenosis): in a review of 4 studies, no pain when seated was the most useful sign.
Sources 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6
What's commonEmerging evidence
In a review of running injuries, the commonest new ones were Achilles tendinopathy (10.3%), shin splints (9.4%) and kneecap pain (6.3%). Of 150 athletes with leg pain on exercise at one centre, 33% had exertional compartment syndrome, 25% stress fractures, 13% shin splints and 10% a trapped nerve, a mix unlikely to match everyone's.
Shin splints affect 5% to 35% of runners; being female, a previous episode, fewer years of running, a higher body mass index (BMI) and using orthotics all go with a higher risk. For a calf strain, increasing age and a previous calf strain are the strongest risk factors, in a review of 10 studies of 5,397 athletes. Outside sport, other causes include narrowed arteries, a clot, varicose veins and nerves from the back.
Sources 7, 4, 8, 9, 5, 10, 11, 12
A stress fractureEmerging evidence
Health New Zealand describes pain in one spot you can point to with a fingertip, worse with activity, and later a constant ache, even at night; it usually takes 6 to 8 weeks to heal. Stress fractures often follow a sudden increase in activity, the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons (AAOS) says. In a review of 2,974 bone stress injuries, return to sport averaged 44 days for the back-inner edge of the shin bone and 56 days for the thinner outer bone (the fibula), and more than 90% returned. The front of the shin bone is a high-risk site that needs protecting for longer.
Sources 3, 13, 14
Compartment syndrome: the exercise kind and the emergencyEmerging evidence
Exertional compartment syndrome is pain, tightness or burning that builds in one group of muscles with exercise and goes with rest. In a review, the front of the shin was the commonest site (45%), and both legs were affected in 85% to 95%. It's confirmed by measuring the pressure in the muscles before and after exercise.
Acute compartment syndrome is an emergency: severe pain, worse when the muscle is stretched and more than you'd expect from the injury, usually after an injury or a cast or bandage that's too tight. It needs surgery as soon as possible. Numbness and weakness are late signs, so don't wait for them.
Sources 4, 15, 16, 17
The calf and the AchillesEmerging evidence
A calf strain is a sudden pull mid-stride or as you push off, tender in one spot, and calf strains often come back. Achilles tendinopathy causes pain and stiffness in the cord above the heel, worst first thing in the morning or after rest, often after a sudden increase in running. An Achilles rupture feels like being hit or kicked at the back of the ankle, followed by walking flat-footed and not being able to stand on tiptoe: it needs help the same day.
Sources 9, 18, 19, 20
Narrowed arteries: claudication and rest painStrong evidence
An ache, cramp or tiredness in the calf, thigh or buttock on walking that goes after a few minutes' rest can be peripheral arterial disease (PAD), a narrowing of the leg arteries. The NHS says many people wrongly think it's just part of growing older, and it's checked by comparing the blood pressure at the ankle and the arm.
Most people with it don't get worse, and many improve with exercise and stopping smoking, the Circulation Foundation says, but 1 to 2 in 100 a year develop severe pain at rest. An international guideline says that pain is often worse lying down and at night and eased by hanging the foot down. It needs a GP immediately.
Sources 5, 21, 22
Nerves and veinsEmerging evidence
Sciatica often spreads from the buttock down the back of the leg into the calf or foot, with burning, tingling or numbness, and NHS inform says calf symptoms that come from the back are usually felt at the back of the calf. Crossing your legs, kneeling or squatting for long periods can injure the nerve at the outer knee that lifts the foot, the NHS says. Burning, tingling or numb feet in both legs can be nerve damage (peripheral neuropathy).
Varicose veins can make the legs ache, feel heavy and swell. A vein that is hard and sore to touch, with warm, red or darkened skin over it, can be phlebitis, which needs checking in case it's a clot.
Sources 12, 23, 24, 25, 11, 26
Tests and scans
Shin splints are diagnosed from the history and an examination: two clinicians examining 46 athletes agreed almost every time (a kappa of 0.89), and 11 of the 34 with shin splints had a second lower leg injury as well. For a suspected stress fracture, an early X-ray may look normal (in a review, it picked up as few as 1 in 10), with changes usually showing after 2 to 8 weeks, while a magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) scan shows bone swelling within about 3 days.
Exertional compartment syndrome is confirmed by measuring the pressure in the muscles before and after exercise. Narrowed arteries are checked by comparing the blood pressure at the ankle and the arm; the National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE) says a normal result doesn't rule them out in people with diabetes. For a suspected clot, NICE's pathway is a clinical score and an ultrasound scan of the leg veins.
Sources 2, 4, 15, 5, 27, 28
How it usually goesEmerging evidence
An NHS physiotherapy leaflet says most new leg pain improves within 6 to 8 weeks, and NHS inform says most new calf problems begin to settle within 6 weeks. Some causes take longer. The NHS says shin splints usually get better within a few weeks, though that page is past its review date; in the Dutch trial below, athletes took a mean of 102 to 118 days to finish a graded running programme.
Stress fractures usually take 6 to 8 weeks to heal. Achilles tendinopathy usually takes several months or more to manage, and NHS inform suggests talking to a professional if it hasn't improved within 12 weeks. With claudication, the benefits of exercise lasted up to 2 years in trials. No one can promise a date.
Sources 29, 23, 30, 31, 3, 18, 32