What a supracondylar fracture is
A break of the upper arm bone (humerus) just above the elbow. US orthopaedic surgeons (the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons) call it the commonest elbow fracture in children, usually under 8, and one of the more serious, because it can injure nerves and affect the blood supply. Most come from a fall onto an outstretched hand or straight onto the elbow.
Doctors grade the break by how far it has moved: type I hasn't moved, type II has partly moved, and type III has moved completely (the Gartland types). Most breaks bend the arm backwards; a less common type, from a fall onto the bent elbow, more often affects the ulnar nerve. Other children's elbow breaks are different injuries: a break of the outer knob of the elbow, of the inner bump (usually at ages 9 to 14), of the top of the radius, and the Monteggia injury.
Sources 1, 2, 3, 4
Who gets itEmerging evidence
In a Danish county, elbow fractures affected 308 in every 100,000 children under 15 each year, and 58% were supracondylar. In US emergency departments, there were 60 to 72 visits for supracondylar fractures for every 100,000 children a year; the average age was 5.5, 54% were aged 3 to 6, and they were about 60% commoner from April to September. In 159 children at a UK hospital, the median age was 6; 46% of breaks were type I, 28% type II and 26% type III; 41% of the children had an operation; falls from play equipment caused 37% of the breaks with a known cause; and nearly twice as many happened each week in the school holidays as in term time.
Typical causes are falls from monkey bars and other playground equipment, sports such as gymnastics and football, skateboarding and cycling, and, for toddlers, falls from lower heights. In Okinawa, these breaks were commonest in boys aged 4 to 7.
Sources 5, 6, 4, 7, 1
How it's recognised
Sudden, intense pain in the elbow and forearm, swelling, and not being able to straighten the arm. A child who complains of elbow pain after a fall and won't or can't move the arm needs a doctor straight away. US orthopaedic surgeons add a snap at the time, loss of elbow movement, a cool and pale hand, numbness or tingling in the fingers, and not being able to move all the fingers.
X-rays confirm it, and doctors sometimes X-ray both elbows, because a child's growing bones can look confusing. Being able to straighten the elbow fully after an injury makes a break less likely, but in a large UK study about 4 in 100 children who could do it still had a break, so a child who isn't using the arm normally still needs an X-ray.
Sources 1, 8, 9
Two things on the X-ray that can confuse
A fat pad sign without a visible break: swelling inside the joint lifts a pad of fat that shows on the X-ray. In 10 studies (250 children) with later scans, 44.6% turned out to have a hidden fracture, most often supracondylar. One NHS service treats a fat pad injury with a sling for about 7 days, says most children improve within the first week, and says physiotherapy isn't needed.
The angles on the X-ray after treatment: in 213 children followed for 2 to 10 years after surgery, the X-ray measures surgeons use to judge the position didn't predict how well the arm worked. A slightly different-looking elbow on the X-ray doesn't by itself mean a worse arm, but a visibly crooked elbow is different: tell the clinic.
Sources 10, 11, 12
Why it's taken seriously
UK orthopaedic standards list nerve injury, a poor blood supply, healing out of line and compartment syndrome as the serious complications.
Nerves: in 40 studies (6,850 children), 11.3% had a nerve injury, most often the median nerve or its branch to the thumb and index finger (60%), then the radial (25%) and ulnar (15%) nerves. Nerve injuries caused by treatment, mostly of the ulnar nerve, happened in 3.7% of operations. Most recovered within 2 to 6 months.
Blood supply: most problems settle once the bones are lined up, and an arm with no signs of a poor blood supply doesn't need the artery explored, whether or not the wrist pulse can be felt. With a pink hand but no wrist pulse, the pulse came back within 24 hours after pinning alone in 61% in pooled studies, and in 94% after the artery was explored.
Compartment syndrome, a dangerous build-up of pressure in the forearm muscles: 21 of 4,308 children admitted (0.49%) needed an operation for it, more often with a nerve injury or a broken forearm on the same side, and it can develop without any risk factors and after treatment. In children, needing more and more painkillers was the earliest sign, and with early treatment over 90% regained full function.
Healing out of line: a break that heals tilted inwards leaves a permanently crooked elbow, with the forearm angled in rather than slightly out (cubitus varus).
Sources 13, 3, 14, 15, 16, 1
Treatment in outline: the fracture clinic decides
A break that hasn't moved (type I) is kept still in a cast or splint. It rarely moves, and about 3 weeks is usually enough. NHS services use a collar and cuff or a cast that parents can take off at home after 2 weeks, or a soft cast or backslab cut off at home at about 3 weeks.
A displaced break is usually lined up under anaesthetic and held with at least two thin wires (Kirschner wires, or K-wires), on the day of the injury, and urgently if the wrist pulse is missing, the hand looks poorly supplied with blood, there's an open wound or the skin is under threat. Teenagers near the end of growing may be treated like adults. A break that has partly moved (type II) may be treated either way.
Afterwards come a backslab or cast, a fracture clinic visit at about 1 week, and the wires out in clinic at about 3 to 4 weeks. Routine long-term follow-up isn't usually needed.
Sources 17, 18, 19, 20, 13, 21, 22
How it usually goesEmerging evidence
A simple break heals well in a cast within 3 to 4 weeks. One NHS service expects about 10 to 12 weeks for the elbow injury as a whole, and many months to get full movement back.
After an operation, without physiotherapy, children had 72% of the other elbow's movement at 6 weeks, 86% at 12 weeks, 94% at 26 weeks and 98% at a year (63 children). In 373 children, the biggest gains came in the first month after the cast came off, with improvement for up to 48 weeks; children over 5 and those who had surgery recovered more slowly. One NHS leaflet warns of marked elbow stiffness for months, with full movement taking up to a year.
In the long run, most children's elbow movement returns to normal or has only a mild limitation. About 4 years after surgery, 30 children had a median arm disability score of 0 out of 100 and near-normal quality of life.
Sources 20, 23, 22, 24, 21, 1, 25