When a lump needs checkingStrong evidence
The NHS says most lumps are harmless, but to see a GP if you're worried or a lump is still there after 2 weeks; if it gets bigger, is painful, red or hot, is hard and does not move, or grows back after it's been removed; and to ask for an urgent GP appointment or get help from NHS 111 for a lump that is very painful, hot or red. A fibroma is firm and fixed, so every new lump in the sole should be checked once.
NICE asks GPs to consider an urgent ultrasound scan, within 2 weeks, for an adult with an unexplained lump that is increasing in size, and within 48 hours for a child or young person, with a specialist referral if the scan is worrying or unclear. The NHS describes a soft tissue sarcoma as a lump that is usually deep, solid, painless and hard to move, and that keeps growing. These are rare, but they are why a growing lump is scanned quickly.
Sources 13, 14, 10, 11, 15
Shoes, insoles and padding: the main treatment, untestedEmerging evidence
An NHS podiatry service advises a supportive shoe with a fastening, such as a trainer, with more cushioning and depth in the sole and arch, and not completely flat shoes. A podiatrist may prescribe insoles with padding that keeps pressure off the lump, which may ease the pain when standing and walking. An NHS podiatric surgery service lists the same first steps, and US foot and ankle surgeons suggest custom insoles once a fibroma has stopped growing.
A walking study supports the idea: 41 people with painful Ledderhose disease put more pressure through the heel and toes, and less under the middle of the foot, than 41 younger people without foot problems. No trial has compared insoles.
Sources 1, 3, 8, 16
What exercise can and can't doEmerging evidence
No exercise shrinks or dissolves a fibroma, and none has been tested. An NHS podiatry service says exercises that stretch the calf and the plantar fascia help ease pain in daily activity, and a surgical service says calf stretches may help, especially with insoles. Exercise keeps you active and your calf and foot strong; it can't change the lump. Moves that press on the lump, such as rolling the arch on a ball or kneeling on tucked toes, are best left out (our caution).
Sources 1, 3
Steroid injections: the sources conflictMixed evidence
Two NHS services say an injection may help only if a nearby nerve is irritated, and is otherwise of little or no benefit and may even make the lump bigger. A US review describes injections as a common first step there, but notes that lumps can return to their original size within 3 years and that repeated injections risk tearing the fascia. In US records, 59% of newly diagnosed people had steroid injections. No trial has tested them.
Sources 1, 3, 2, 4
Radiotherapy: one good trialEmerging evidence
In the LedRad trial, 84 people in the Netherlands had real or sham (dummy) radiotherapy without knowing which. At 12 months, average pain was 2.5 out of 10 after real treatment against 3.6 after sham, and 2.1 against 3.4 at 18 months; 74% against 56% had pain relief at 12 months, with better quality of life and faster barefoot walking. Side effects (redness, dry skin, burning and a short-lived rise in pain) were mild in 95% and had gone in 87% by 18 months.
In 67 people (102 feet) followed for several years after treatment, pain fell from 5.7 to 1.7 out of 10, and 78% were satisfied; 15% had lasting dry skin. It was judged good value for money in the Netherlands. It is one trial, and NICE has no guideline on it, so ask a specialist whether it is offered locally.
Sources 17, 18, 19, 20
Collagenase and shockwave: not shown to work yetMixed evidence
A collagenase injection, an enzyme that breaks down the tough tissue, missed its main pain target against a placebo in a trial of 166 people, though more people were rated as improved overall and the lumps got softer; a larger trial is under way. Collagenase (Xiapex) isn't available in the UK: its licence was withdrawn in 2020, and NICE has withdrawn its guidance on it for Dupuytren's contracture.
Shockwave therapy has only small studies without a comparison group: pain fell from 6.2 to 0.6 out of 10 in 10 feet, and from about 6 to 1 in 6 people. Other drugs rest on laboratory work and Dupuytren's studies, not plantar fibroma trials.
Sources 21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26, 2
Surgery: a last resort, because fibromas often come backEmerging evidence
How often a fibroma comes back after surgery depends on the operation and the study. In a review of 6 studies (109 feet), it came back after 67% of operations removing the lump alone, 42% of wider removals with a margin of fascia, and 27% of operations removing the fascia. In another review, the figures ranged from 57% to 100% after removing the lump alone, 8% to 80% after a wider removal and 0% to 50% after removing all the fascia, about 60% overall in that review, and more often with both feet affected, several lumps or a family history. A UK series of partial fasciectomy, removing part of the fascia, had 1 recurrence in 18 people at up to 5 years, and an NHS podiatric surgery service quotes 15% to 50%.
Other risks include a thick or tender scar, numbness, a flatter, achy arch and slow wound healing, and the NHS service warns that when surgery fails, things can be worse than before, with little chance that more surgery helps. In US records, only 6.8% of newly diagnosed people had surgery. A review of 25 studies (233 people) found the evidence for every treatment thin, and called for better trials.
Sources 27, 2, 28, 3, 4, 29
No NICE guideline, because the evidence is thinStrong evidence
In February 2025, NICE decided not to produce a guideline on plantar fibromatosis, because there is very limited evidence on it; it will look at adding it to its clinical summary on Dupuytren's disease. So treatment depends on local specialists, and the advice on this page comes from NHS leaflets, reviews and a few trials.
Source 20