What it isStrong evidence
The tarsal tunnel is a narrow passage behind and below the bony bump on the inside of the ankle, roofed by a band of tough tissue (the flexor retinaculum). Three tendons, an artery, veins and the tibial nerve run through it. In or near the tunnel the nerve splits into two branches that supply the sole (the medial and lateral plantar nerves), and a small branch supplies the skin of the heel.
Tarsal tunnel syndrome means the nerve or its branches are squeezed in this tunnel. The branches then pass under a muscle on the inner side of the foot (abductor hallucis), so they can also be squeezed just below the ankle. One small branch there, sometimes called Baxter's nerve, can cause heel pain when it is trapped.
Sources 1, 2, 3
How it feelsEmerging evidence
Burning, tingling, pins and needles or numbness in the sole, heel or inner ankle, sometimes with shooting pain. It can spread into the toes or, less often, up the calf. In one series of 59 people, tingling or burning was the commonest symptom (86% of feet), followed by pain (55%).
It is usually in one foot: only 6 of those 59 people had it in both. It tends to build with standing and walking and as the day goes on, is often worse at night, and is eased by rest, raising the foot or rubbing it.
Sources 4, 2, 5
How it's recognisedEmerging evidence
A clinician presses and taps over the nerve behind the inner ankle bone. Pressing hurts in 60 to 100% of people with it, and tapping sends tingling into the foot (Tinel's sign) in more than half. Holding the foot pulled up and turned out, with the toes bent back, brought on symptoms in 82% of 44 feet that later had surgery, and in none of 100 healthy feet.
These tests aren't specific, though. In cadavers, that position also stretches the plantar fascia, and the usual test for plantar fasciitis also stretches the nerves in the sole, so neither test cleanly separates the two. Late signs are numbness on testing, weak toe muscles and wasting of the small foot muscles.
Sources 2, 6, 7
Who gets it, and whyEmerging evidence
It is uncommon, and nobody knows exactly how common. Some authors think it is often missed; experienced nerve surgeons warn that it is diagnosed too often. It is more common in women, and is seen in active people and runners. Reviews of case series list these causes:
- A past ankle injury, such as a sprain or a fracture, in 17 to 43% of cases.
- Something taking up space in the tunnel: a ganglion (a fluid-filled lump, in up to 8%), swollen or tangled veins, a fatty lump or, rarely, a nerve tumour.
- Swollen tendon sheaths, arthritis, an extra or enlarged muscle, or a bar of bone or tough tissue joining two foot bones (a tarsal coalition).
- Foot shape: a heel that tips outwards or a foot that rolls in. In cadavers, turning the foot fully outwards raised the pressure in the tunnel from 2 to 32 mmHg (millimetres of mercury), and turning it fully inwards raised it to 17.
- Conditions that affect the whole body: diabetes, an underactive thyroid, or kidney failure needing dialysis.
- No cause found in about a fifth to over half of cases, depending on the series. In one surgical series of 50 feet, 18 had a ganglion, 15 a tarsal coalition and 9 no clear cause.
Sources 1, 3, 2, 8, 9, 5, 10
Plantar fasciitis, a trapped heel nerve, or both?Emerging evidence
Tarsal tunnel syndrome is often mistaken for plantar fasciitis, and a trapped nerve at the heel, especially Baxter's nerve, is a recognised cause of heel pain with or without plantar fasciitis. The two can occur together: in a clinic that injected 218 people for tarsal tunnel syndrome, 38% of the 68 who had an MRI (magnetic resonance imaging) scan also showed signs of plantar fasciitis.
A third look-alike is irritation of the big toe's long tendon (flexor hallucis longus), which runs through the same tunnel. In 81 people with it, the pain was behind the inner ankle in 40 and under the heel in 23, and 45 had already had treatment that didn't work, usually for plantar fasciitis.
Clues that point to the nerve: burning, tingling or numbness; symptoms that build with standing and at night, rather than pain on the first steps that eases; and tingling when the inner ankle is tapped. Don't try to settle this on your own: the NHS advises seeing a GP for tingling or loss of feeling in the foot.
Sources 3, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15
Diabetic nerve damage, or a trapped nerve?Emerging evidence
Peripheral neuropathy (damage to the nerves of the hands and feet) affects about 1 in 10 people aged 55 or over in the UK, and diabetes is its commonest cause here. It usually starts in both feet, in the toes, and creeps upwards, with numbness, burning or stabbing pain and poor balance. Tarsal tunnel syndrome is usually one foot, centred on the inner ankle and sole.
They can occur together. Tapping over the nerve at the ankle set off tingling in 45% of 416 people with diabetes and in about a quarter of 196 without. In a group of people with diabetes, those with tarsal tunnel syndrome in both feet developed more new foot ulcers over about 2 years (17% against 8%). So any new numbness or pain in the feet with diabetes needs your diabetes team or GP.
Sources 16, 17, 4, 18, 19
When the back is the source
A trapped nerve root in the lower back can also cause tingling in the sole of one foot. In 561 people with a trapped nerve root in the lower back, 27 (about 5%) also had tarsal tunnel syndrome. Back pain, or symptoms running down the back of the leg, point to the sciatica guide.
Sources 3, 20
What tests and scans do and don't showEmerging evidence
Nerve conduction studies can support the diagnosis, but an evidence review couldn't work out how often they get it right or wrong, and the results need comparing with the other foot. In 32 feet that had surgery, the test results didn't predict who did well.
A tingle when the ankle is tapped isn't proof either: it was found in about a quarter of people without diabetes or any nerve symptoms.
An ultrasound or MRI scan looks for a cause, such as a ganglion, swollen veins or a lump, and helps plan surgery; MRI found a relevant problem in 85 to 88% of people with the diagnosis. A scan isn't needed for everyone. It matters when a lump is felt, symptoms are getting worse, or surgery is being considered.
Sources 21, 1, 2, 22, 18, 3
How it usually goesMixed evidence
There is little good evidence on how it goes without treatment. In one small series, 6 of 9 people who had no treatment improved or recovered. In one clinic's records of 218 people given a guided steroid injection, 77.5% did not go on to have surgery over an average of 11 months, but there was no comparison group, so some would have settled anyway. Only three studies have reported the results of non-surgical care at all.
Sources 5, 13, 1