Changing how you run did as well as adding exercise or gait retrainingEmerging evidence
In a trial of 69 runners with kneecap pain, education on symptoms and training did as well on its own as with added exercise or with gait retraining, over 20 weeks. The advice was to run more slowly, spread your running across the week, use run-walk intervals, and avoid running downhill and down stairs. The exercises did build strength and the retraining did change how people ran, but neither added pain relief.
It was one small trial, and in kneecap pain, so we borrow its advice for other running knee pain (our suggestion).
Sources 20, 21
Hip and knee strengthening is the core treatmentStrong evidence
In a Cochrane review of 31 trials (1,690 people), exercise reduced kneecap pain during activity by about 1.5 points out of 10 in the short term against no exercise, and hip plus knee exercise reduced it by a further 2.2 points against knee exercise alone (3 trials, 104 people). The trials were small and low quality, but the results were consistent.
Two international consensus statements recommend exercise, with hip and knee work combined in preference to knee work alone. An NHS leaflet for kneecap pain starts with 3 sets of 8 to 12, including mini squats to less than 30° of knee bend.
Sources 22, 23, 24, 25
Hip strength for IT band painEmerging evidence
Across 13 small studies (201 runners), strengthening the muscles on the outside of the hip was the commonest treatment for IT band syndrome, with pain falling by 27 to 100% over 2 to 8 weeks; the studies were too different to pool. In 24 distance runners with the condition, the sore side's hip muscles were weaker, and a successful return to running went with regaining that strength over 6 weeks. That was a case series without a comparison group.
Sources 26, 27
A slightly quicker step eases the load on the kneeEmerging evidence
This is mostly lab work in healthy runners: 5 to 10% more steps a minute at the same pace lowered the load at the knee. Trials in people with knee pain are small. In 30 runners with kneecap pain, 2 weeks of retraining (a quicker step, or softer landings) eased running pain by about 3 points out of 10 at 6 months against no retraining, and 12 runners in a case series ran further without pain after one session with a metronome. A review of reviews found short-term gains in pain and function.
But in the 69-runner trial, education alone did as well as education plus gait retraining, and a meta-analysis calls the evidence on pain very limited; a quicker step also felt harder and more awkward at first. It's worth trying, not a cure.
Sources 9, 10, 28, 29, 30, 20, 31
A staged programme helps patellar tendon painEmerging evidence
In the largest trial (76 people), a staged programme of holds, then slow strength work, then springy loading including running drills, then sport, with pain kept at 3 out of 10 or less, improved a tendon score by 28 points against 18 with painful eccentric squats at 24 weeks. More returned to sport (43% against 27%), though that difference could be chance. A review warns that tendon rehab can be slow and sometimes frustrating.
Sources 32, 14
Shoes and insoles: comfort firstEmerging evidence
No type of running shoe has been shown to prevent injuries, and choosing shoes by foot shape made no difference in 3 trials of 7,203 military recruits. In 927 new runners in neutral shoes, feet that rolled in weren't injured more. One blinded trial of 372 runners is the exception: motion-control shoes lowered injuries, but only in runners whose feet rolled in, while another trial found shoes prescribed by foot type led to more missed training. Comfort is a sensible guide: runners who rated their shoes well cushioned and liked them had fewer injuries in one analysis.
For kneecap pain, ready-made arch-support insoles are recommended for short-term relief, though the average benefit is small and not everyone gains.
Sources 33, 34, 35, 36, 37, 38, 23
Running doesn't wear out healthy kneesEmerging evidence
In pooled studies, recreational runners had less hip and knee arthritis (3.5%) than people who didn't run (10.2%), though competitive runners had more (13.3%). In 1,203 people aged 50 or over with knee arthritis, those who chose to run had no faster X-ray changes and no more new knee pain, and their pain eased more often. In 3,804 marathon runners, years of running and weekly distance didn't predict arthritis, while age, body weight, past knee injury or surgery and family history did.
Sources 39, 40, 41