0 to 2 is safe, up to 5 is acceptable, and the end of the bend is a stretch, not a pinchEmerging evidence
This guide uses the knee hub's rule. Rate your knee pain from 0 to 10 during and after exercise. In the pain-monitoring model used in knee trials, 0 to 2 counts as safe, up to 5 as acceptable and above 5 as too much. Aim for 0 to 3 most of the time.
By the next morning your knee should be back to its usual level. If it is not, drop back one step next time (fewer sets, a shallower range, a lower step), not to nothing. Over the weeks pain should hold steady or ease; that last check is our suggestion rather than a tested rule.
Some knee programmes say you should feel no pain at all. The trials allowed some, and a meta-analysis found exercising into some pain did no worse than pain-free exercise. With arthritis, NICE says joint pain may rise when you start exercising, and that regular exercise still helps in the long run.
Sharp, catching or giving-way pain, or new swelling, is a reason to stop and get it checked.
When you bend (our suggestion): a stretch or ache at the end of the bend that eases within a few minutes of straightening is fine. Bend to just short of that point in the exercises, and go a little further each week. A sharp pinch, catching that doesn't free up, a block to straightening, or swelling that is bigger the next morning are reasons to stop and get it checked. With kneecap pain, start squats at about 45° and seated knee extensions from 90° to 45°, which loaded the kneecap least in a lab study, then go deeper. Straightening exercises should feel like a firm stretch at the back of the knee, not a sharp pain; NHS inform's stretch holds build to 20 to 30 seconds.
A tendon that hurts at one point just above or below the kneecap has a stricter limit, about 3 out of 10, as our jumper's knee guide explains.
Sources 19, 31, 32, 16, 2, 23