Night pain is part of the common shoulder problemsStrong evidence
Shoulder pain is common: about 1 in 3 adults have it at some point, an NHS trust says, and it lists discomfort when lying on the painful side at night among the usual symptoms. Rotator cuff related pain, also called subacromial pain, is "the most common reason for shoulder pain", NHS inform says, and frozen shoulder and arthritis are the other two common causes from mid-life.
Night pain is part of the picture for all three. With subacromial pain "it may be difficult to lie on the affected shoulder which can disturb your sleep" (NHS inform), and the NHS says impingement pain "may be worse at night while you're sleeping". Frozen shoulder pain "can be worse at night and disturb sleep" (the NHS) and "is often worse at night and when you lie on the affected side" (NHS inform), and the Chartered Society of Physiotherapy (CSP) says it gives "quite significant pain, especially at night". With a rotator cuff tear, pain at rest and at night is common, especially lying on that shoulder, and with shoulder arthritis "night pain is common, and sleeping may be difficult", say the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons' patient pages.
Sources 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9
Sleep and shoulder pain go togetherEmerging evidence
Poor sleep is the rule rather than the exception once shoulder pain lasts. In 130 people with shoulder pain for 3 months or more, 81.5% had disturbed sleep, far more than in people without pain, and worse pain went with worse sleep. Across 4 studies of people with rotator cuff tears, 40.8% to 89.0% slept poorly; in 20 people wearing activity monitors, sleep was shorter and more broken than in people without tears in earlier studies; and in 343 people with shoulder problems, sleep was poorest with frozen shoulder.
The link may run both ways: in 1,454 adults followed for 2 years after the 2011 Japanese earthquake, poor sleep went with new shoulder pain (about twice the odds). That's one unusual group, so it can't prove that poor sleep causes shoulder pain.
Sources 10, 11, 12, 13, 14
Why the shoulder hurts more in bed: what's known and what's guessedEmerging evidence
Lying on the shoulder presses on it. In a lab study of 20 healthy volunteers, pressure under the roof of the shoulder (the subacromial space) was lower lying on the back than on the side or front. People with pain in one shoulder often lie on it: in 83 people, 67% of those who slept on one side slept on the painful side.
Other explanations are research ideas, not tests you can use: blood flow in a small artery at the front of the shoulder was higher in people with night pain from rotator cuff tears, especially lying down in a group whose night pain eased by sitting up; shoulder tissue from people with tears or frozen shoulder showed more receptors for melatonin, the sleep hormone; and in 61 people with rotator cuff related pain, worse night pain went with more disability and with changes in one rotator cuff tendon on a magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) scan.
Sources 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20
Does sleeping on your side cause shoulder problems?Mixed evidence
It hasn't been shown. The idea was put forward as a hypothesis, and in one clinic 52 of 58 people with rotator cuff tears were side sleepers, but there was no comparison group. In 761 workers, sleeping position wasn't linked with shoulder pain or rotator cuff tendinopathy, and sleeping with the arms overhead went with less pain, not more; the authors suggest people with sore shoulders may already avoid some positions.
Side sleeping is normal: in 664 workers wearing sensors, people spent about 54% of their time in bed on their side, and changed position about 1.6 times an hour.
Sources 21, 22, 23, 24
When night pain needs checkingStrong evidence
What matters is the company night pain keeps. An NHS trust advises contacting a GP or NHS 111 urgently for new, unexplained shoulder pain with a history of cancer, HIV, TB or inflammatory arthritis, or with feeling unwell, loss of appetite, a fever, weight loss or night sweats. The NHS says see a GP for pain in a bone "particularly if it's worse at night". Lung problems can cause shoulder pain: the NHS lists chest or shoulder pain among lung cancer symptoms, Arthritis UK says a doctor may suggest a chest X-ray for unexplained shoulder pain lasting more than 3 weeks in a smoker over 40, and the National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE) asks GPs to arrange an urgent chest X-ray for people 40 and over with two or more unexplained symptoms such as a cough, tiredness, breathlessness, chest pain or weight loss (one, if they have ever smoked).
On its own, night pain is a weak sign. In older people sent for a test for a rotator cuff tear, night pain was a weaker sign of a tear than weakness turning the arm out or being 65 or over. In 482 people at a back pain clinic, 213 had night pain and none was found to have a serious disease; that study was in back pain, not shoulder pain.
Sources 1, 25, 26, 27, 4, 28, 29
When a scan helpsStrong evidence
Usually not at first. An NHS trust says scans aren't required in most cases of rotator cuff related pain, because "many of the structural changes that are seen on a scan are normal particularly as we get older". Rotator cuff changes on scans are common without pain, and rise from about 10% of people at 20 or under to 62% at 80 or over.
A health professional may arrange an X-ray to check the cause, which shows arthritis and calcium deposits. An ultrasound or MRI scan matters after an injury with weakness, when a repair may be needed. A chest X-ray is for the lung signs in the warning list.
Sources 30, 31, 32, 26
How it usually goesEmerging evidence
Most new shoulder pain improves within 6 to 8 weeks, an NHS trust says, and NHS inform says a new problem or a flare should begin to settle within 6 weeks; the NHS says self-care usually takes 2 weeks to start helping, and recovery can take 6 months or longer. In 349 people seeing a GP with new shoulder pain, 23% had recovered at a month and 59% at a year; neck pain and severe daytime pain at the start went with slower recovery. Night pain hasn't been shown to predict a worse outcome.
Rotator cuff related pain often takes a while: about half of cases settle within about 6 months without treatment, an NHS hospital trust says, and with exercise an NHS trust expects at least 12 weeks, sometimes up to 24, perhaps with little change in the first 6. Frozen shoulder can take more than 2 years. Night pain usually eases as the daytime pain does: in one exercise trial it fell from 46 to 15 out of 100 over 3 months, and after rotator cuff repair, sleep improved within 6 months. No one can promise a date.
Sources 1, 33, 32, 34, 35, 36, 30, 7, 4, 37, 11