Women with bladder painEmerging evidence
In 81 women with bladder pain (interstitial cystitis) for 3 months to 3 years and a tender pelvic floor, up to 10 hour-long sessions of hands-on myofascial physiotherapy led 59% to report moderate or marked improvement, against 26% after full-body massage. Pain, urgency and frequency scores improved in both groups and didn't differ between them, and how long the benefit lasted wasn't measured. Side effects, mostly pain, were similar in both groups, and none was serious.
Source 7
The first trial, in women and menEmerging evidence
In a 2009 feasibility trial of 47 people (23 men with chronic prostatitis or pelvic pain syndrome and 24 people with bladder pain), 57% responded to myofascial physiotherapy against 21% to general massage. But in the men, massage worked about as well, so the difference was only in the bladder pain group. Side effects, mainly pain, were reported by 52% after myofascial therapy and 21% after massage, and over 90% of people knew which treatment they'd had.
Source 9
Pooled trialsMixed evidence
A review of 7 trials found hands-on myofascial therapies weren't significantly better than standard care for pain, symptoms or quality of life in chronic pelvic pain, on very low certainty evidence, though there was a trend in their favour.
Source 10
Men: hands-on treatmentEmerging evidence
The evidence for hands-on release in men is weak: in the one trial, men did about as well with general massage. A Cochrane review of 38 trials of treatments without medicines for chronic prostatitis and pelvic pain syndrome found the best evidence for acupuncture and shockwave therapy (high certainty, short term), and the effects of most other treatments were uncertain. The NHS lists physiotherapy, talking therapy and acupuncture among the options a urologist may offer.
Sources 9, 22, 23
Men: exercise and yogaEmerging evidence
A network meta-analysis of 15 trials (1,736 men), which we read as an abstract and which was built mostly on small trials, found exercise-based treatments, led by pelvic floor training with electrical stimulation, eased symptoms more than standard medical care, on low to moderate certainty evidence. In 40 men, an hour of supervised yoga a day for 6 weeks did about as well as two medicines, with fewer side effects.
Sources 24, 25
Pain at the entrance to the vaginaEmerging evidence
In 212 women with provoked vestibulodynia (pain when the vaginal entrance is touched), 10 weekly sessions of physiotherapy, combining education, pelvic floor exercises with biofeedback, hands-on therapy and dilators, beat a numbing lidocaine cream for pain during sex by 1.8 points out of 10, still there at 6 months. In the physiotherapy group, 79% felt much or very much better, against 39% with the cream. It's one large trial, with masked assessors and no sham.
Source 8
Vulvodynia and painful sexEmerging evidence
A network meta-analysis of 34 trials (1,893 women with vulvodynia), which we read as an abstract and which was built mostly on small trials, found physiotherapy-based treatment, acupuncture and psychological therapy all eased pain against no treatment, while a placebo also eased it by about 14 points out of 100. A BMJ review says guidelines recommend pelvic floor physiotherapy with psychological support first for vulvodynia, though its benefit for constant, unprovoked pain isn't established.
Smaller reviews of physiotherapy and manual therapy for painful sex found benefits in small studies of mixed quality. In one trial of 42 women around the menopause, five sessions of treatment at the pelvis eased pain during sex more than the same time spent on the low back and hips.
Sources 26, 14, 27, 28, 29, 30, 31
What guidelines sayStrong evidence
The American Urological Association's guideline says hands-on physiotherapy that releases pelvic, tummy and hip trigger points and tight connective tissue should be offered to people with bladder pain and a tender pelvic floor, where trained clinicians are available, and that pelvic floor strengthening (Kegel exercises) should be avoided. The European Association of Urology gives myofascial treatment a weak recommendation as the first treatment for pelvic floor problems in chronic pelvic pain, while noting there's no evidence that hands-on techniques for trigger points beat no treatment. The National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE) lists chronic pelvic pain among pelvic floor problems and defines pelvic floor training as including relaxation, but makes no recommendation on hands-on release.
Sources 16, 17, 32
Pelvic wandsMixed evidence
The only safety reports come from uncontrolled studies by the protocol's developers, in people with long-standing pain, mostly men, who were trained in a clinic first and then used an internal wand at home with relaxation training. They reported less tenderness and less use of medicines, with no comparison group, so no general safety claim can be made. An expert consensus suggests wands mainly for people who can't get to a physiotherapist. Use one only with a pelvic health physiotherapist's guidance.
Sources 33, 34, 35, 2