Where it hurts is the best clueStrong evidence
The NHS sorts thumb pain by its pattern: pain, swelling and bruising after an injury points to a sprain or a break; pain, swelling and stiffness at the base that lasts, sometimes with a lump, to de Quervain's or arthritis; aching that is worse at night, with numbness or a weak thumb, to carpal tunnel syndrome; and pain at the base on the palm side with clicking to a trigger thumb. It asks you not to self-diagnose, and the map above is a guide to the likely cause, not a diagnosis.
NHS inform adds that pins and needles, or sharp, hot or burning pain, in the hand or thumb can come from the neck, even when the neck doesn't hurt.
Sources 1, 2, 3
Thumb base arthritis: common on X-rays, a problem for fewer peopleStrong evidence
The base of the thumb, where it meets a small wrist bone, is one of the commonest places for osteoarthritis. On X-rays it is common and rises with age: in 16 population studies, about 5.8% of men and 7.3% of women had it at 50, and 33.1% and 39.0% at 80; in 7,792 Dutch adults aged 55 and over, 25.3% had it. Far fewer see a doctor about it: in southern Sweden, 1.4% of adults (2.2% of women and 0.62% of men) had a doctor's diagnosis, most often women aged 70 to 74 (5.3%).
Women are 2 to 3 times more likely to get it, US orthopaedic surgeons say. In a Finnish study of 3,595 adults, a higher body weight went with it and heavy physical work didn't, though a study like this shows a link, not a cause. Many people with these changes on an X-ray have little or no pain, UK and US hand surgeons say. The NHS describes a bump at the base of the thumb and trouble writing, opening jars or turning keys.
Sources 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10
De Quervain's, a trigger thumb and a torn ligamentEmerging evidence
De Quervain's affects two thumb tendons in a tunnel on the thumb side of the wrist. Pain is worse lifting the thumb, as in the hitchhiker position, or using scissors; mothers of small babies seem particularly prone, and there is little evidence that it is caused by work, though hand use aggravates it, UK hand surgeons say. In the 30 treatment trials, 80% of people were women, with an average age of 46.
In a trigger thumb, a thickened tendon catches at the mouth of its tunnel, so the thumb clicks, sticks bent or needs pushing straight, often worse in the morning. The NHS says it is more likely over 40, with diabetes or with rheumatoid arthritis, and hand surgeons add that it isn't caused by arthritis.
Skier's thumb is a tear of the ligament on the index-finger side of the thumb's knuckle, usually from a fall onto the thumb while gripping something, such as a ski pole. Less often the ligament stretches slowly over years (gamekeeper's thumb), with a weak pinch. The NHS lists the thumb among the commonest places for sprains.
Sources 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18
Phones, gaming and repeated thumb use: what the studies showEmerging evidence
In 18 studies of university students, 19.2% to 68.7% reported wrist, hand or thumb pain, linked with time on the phone, how it is held, frequent thumb movements and the screen's size and weight. Across 42 studies of over 67,000 mostly young people (average age 24.6), phone use was linked with de Quervain's, carpal tunnel syndrome and tendon problems. In 7,092 young Swedish adults, texting predicted new hand and finger symptoms a year later (an odds ratio of 2.0, roughly double the odds), mostly short-lived.
In 477 students followed for 6 months, those who no longer met a threshold for smartphone addiction had less pain and fewer tendon changes on ultrasound, while those who stayed hooked didn't improve despite some cut in screen time. All these studies are observational: they show links, not cause and effect. No study we read links phone use to thumb arthritis, which is uncommon before 50. The NHS calls pain from repeated movements repetitive strain injury.
Sources 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 4
Other causes, each with its own clues
These are less common, but they need a different kind of help:
- Carpal tunnel syndrome: numbness, tingling or pins and needles in the thumb and first two fingers, a weak thumb or difficulty gripping, usually worse at night.
- Rheumatoid arthritis: several swollen, stiff joints, often in both hands, with long morning stiffness. NICE asks GPs to refer it urgently when the small joints of the hands are affected, even if blood tests are normal.
- Gout or a joint infection: a sudden, hot, red, swollen joint, with a high temperature in an infection.
- Paronychia: sore, red, swollen and warm skin around the nail, which can be an infection.
- A torn thumb tendon: weeks after a broken wrist, or with rheumatoid arthritis, the thumb suddenly can't be lifted off a flat table, sometimes after a 'ping'.
- A young child's trigger thumb: a thumb stuck bent, rarely painful, which usually gets better on its own within up to 2 years.
Sources 24, 25, 26, 27, 28, 29, 30, 31, 2
Tests and scansStrong evidence
NICE diagnoses osteoarthritis without an X-ray in people aged 45 or over with joint pain on activity and morning stiffness of 30 minutes or less, and doesn't use imaging to guide treatment. US orthopaedic surgeons use a grind test (pressing and turning the thumb base) and say X-rays can confirm arthritis, though some people with advanced changes have no symptoms.
After an injury it's different: the NHS says you'll probably need an X-ray, because a break, a dislocation and a bad sprain are hard to tell apart. For a possible torn ligament, the UK hand surgeons' guideline asks for a history, an examination and X-rays, and found too little evidence to recommend routine ultrasound or magnetic resonance imaging (MRI). A nerve test may be used for carpal tunnel syndrome, and blood tests and a specialist referral for possible rheumatoid arthritis.
Sources 32, 8, 33, 17, 24, 26
How it usually goesEmerging evidence
New thumb problems, or a flare-up of an old one, should begin to settle within 6 weeks, NHS inform says; the NHS asks you to see a GP if it hasn't improved after 2 weeks of treating it at home. Osteoarthritis doesn't necessarily get worse and can sometimes gradually improve, the NHS says, and thumb base arthritis may become less bothersome over time, with symptoms often settling over the long term.
Some mild trigger thumbs recover over a few weeks without treatment, and an injection relieves a trigger thumb or de Quervain's in about 7 in 10, hand surgeons say. A broken thumb usually heals in 6 to 8 weeks, with full strength by 3 to 4 months. Phone-related pain eased in students whose heavy phone habit eased. No one can promise a timescale.
Sources 2, 1, 34, 8, 9, 14, 11, 33, 35, 22