What it is
The thumb's knuckle (the metacarpophalangeal joint) is steadied on the index-finger side by the ulnar collateral ligament (UCL), which takes the load when you pinch or grip. A force that bends the thumb away from the hand sprains or tears it. Clinicians grade it: grade 1 is a sprain with no extra looseness, grade 2 a partial tear that is looser but still stops firmly when tested, and grade 3 a complete tear with no firm stop. Sometimes a small piece of bone comes away with the ligament (an avulsion fracture).
Gamekeeper's thumb first described the same ligament stretching slowly over years; skier's thumb is the sudden injury. The ligament on the other side of the knuckle, the radial collateral ligament, is injured about 10 times less often.
Sources 1, 2, 3, 4, 5
The Stener lesionMixed evidence
In a Stener lesion, the torn end of the ligament flips over a sheet of thumb muscle (the adductor aponeurosis), which then lies between the ligament and the bone, so the ligament can't heal back by itself. How often this happens in complete tears varies hugely between studies, from 11% to 87%. The UK guideline found no study showing that a Stener lesion can be reliably diagnosed by examination or by a scan.
Sources 1, 5, 3, 6
Who gets it
About 50 in every 100,000 emergency department visits are for this injury. In skiing it is by far the commonest hand injury and may be the commonest ski injury of all, though it often goes unreported; the pole is the probable cause, since snowboarders rarely get it. At one Vermont resort it became less common in skiers over 18 seasons. In an Italian ski hospital, 33 of 195 people with forearm, wrist or hand injuries (17%) had a torn thumb UCL alone, often after the pole caught.
It also happens in ball sports, hockey, falls and tackles: anything that forces the thumb away from the hand.
Sources 7, 3, 8, 9, 10, 5, 11
How it's recognised
Pain, swelling and bruising at the base of the thumb on the index-finger side, pain and weakness when pinching, and sometimes a loose feeling or a firm lump, which can be a Stener lesion. The key test is a specialist's stress test: gently pushing the thumb sideways with the knuckle straight and then bent, and comparing it with the other thumb. A local anaesthetic injection sometimes helps, though most UK clinicians rarely or never use one.
The UK guideline counts the thumb as significantly loose if there is no firm stop, it opens more than 30°, or it opens more than 20° further than the other thumb. The injury is easily missed: junior A&E doctors correctly diagnosed only 45% of complete tears in one UK study.
Sources 1, 5, 6, 7, 3, 12
What X-rays and scans do and don't showMixed evidence
X-rays in two directions are part of the first assessment, mainly to look for a piece of bone, and children need proper thumb views. A fragment that has moved back past the joint (the displaced fleck sign, seen in 7.5% of 228 people) meant a complete tear in all of them and a Stener lesion in 94%.
Ultrasound and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) are used routinely in some centres (46% of 37 UK centres). Pooled studies suggest ultrasound is accurate for Stener lesions, but every study had a high risk of bias, and across 12 studies in the UK guideline its sensitivity ranged from 40% to 100%. In one recent UK series, 37% of the tears that ultrasound called complete, and that went to surgery, had an intact ligament, though an older UK series found ultrasound right 94% of the times it showed a tear. MRI picked up damage to the ligament well (97%) but was less accurate about the type of tear, and it didn't change who needed surgery beyond a careful examination.
The UK guideline found too little evidence to recommend routine ultrasound or MRI.
Sources 6, 13, 14, 7, 15, 16, 12, 17
How it usually goes
Sprains and partial tears usually heal well in a splint or cast. For complete tears the outlook is less certain: in groups treated in splints and reported in 1989 and 1995, 7% to 15% didn't settle and needed surgery. A complete tear that stays loose can cause long-term pain, a weak pinch and arthritis, and old injuries may need a tendon graft or a fusion of the joint.
Recovery takes time: one NHS trust says full recovery after a collateral ligament injury can take 3 to 6 months.
Sources 1, 6, 18, 19, 20, 5, 21