Muscle activity on all foursEmerging evidence
In 24 healthy adults, the all-fours kickback worked the glute max at 59.7% of its maximum on the moving leg, eighth of 18 rehab exercises; a forearm plank lifting one bent leg came first, at 106.2%. A review of bodyweight exercises found 32.2% with the knee bent and 29.9% with it straight in one study of 20 people, against 39.9% for the single-leg bridge. In an industry-funded study of 12 people, the all-fours kickback had the highest glute activity of 8 exercises without any added weight, though nearly all were statistically similar.
Sources 1, 2, 12
Cable kickbacksEmerging evidence
15 resistance-trained women did 3 reps at 75% of their estimated maximum of six exercises. Peak glute activity in cable kickbacks, as in step-ups, was higher than in Nordic curls and leg curls, and average glute activity, as in 45-degree hip extensions, was too. Cable kickbacks also worked the outer hamstring more than Romanian deadlifts, step-ups and hip extensions.
Source 3
Knee angleEmerging evidence
In 20 adults pushing a leg back as hard as they could while lying face down, hip extension force fell as the knee bent past 60 degrees, the outer hamstring worked hardest with the knee straight, and the glute max outworked the hamstrings at 60, 90 and 110 degrees of knee bend.
Sources 7, 2
Bracing keeps your back out of itEmerging evidence
In 20 adults (10 men, 10 women) lifting a leg while lying face down, drawing the tummy in, checked with a pressure cuff, cut lower-back muscle activity from 49% to 17% of maximum, raised glute activity from 24% to 52% and cut the pelvis's forward tilt from 10 to 3 degrees. In 30 adults, drawing in raised glute activity more in those with a deep lower-back curve.
Sources 8, 14
Growth: one small MRI trialEmerging evidence
17 young adults trained one leg with cable hip extension and the other with cable hip abduction, twice a week for 10 weeks, about 10 sets a week of 8 to 12 reps. The glute max grew 9% with hip extension and 5% with abduction; extension grew its lower part most (upper 5%, middle 8%, lower 14%), and abduction its upper part (10%, 4%, 1%) and the side glutes. We could read only the summary, which doesn't describe the cable set-up.
Source 4
Training grows the glutesStrong evidence
Across 11 pooled studies in a review of 318 people, training grew the glute max by a moderate amount, with single exercises and combinations alike. The review lists hip thrusts, squats, leg presses and kneeling hip extensions among the exercises that grew it.
Source 5
Hip thrusts against squatsEmerging evidence
In untrained college-aged adults training for 9 weeks, glute growth on MRI was similar with hip thrusts and back squats, slightly favouring the hip thrust with wide variation, and the squats grew the front and inner thighs more. No trial has compared kickbacks with either.
Source 6
Donkey kicks with ankle weightsMixed evidence
111 women aged 18 to 30 did squats with a 5 kg bar, donkey kicks with 2.5 kg at each ankle, or nothing, 3 times a week for 6 weeks. "Muscle bulk" was measured as hip circumference, which fell after donkey kicks along with skinfold thickness, so the trial can't tell us whether the glutes grew.
Source 15
Heavier lifts work the glutes hard tooEmerging evidence
A review of 16 studies found very high glute activity in step-ups, hex bar and conventional deadlifts, hip thrusts, split squats and lunges. Kickbacks weren't among the loaded exercises studied.
Source 16