First, the checks a limp needsStrong evidence
Most limps in children aren't serious and get better by themselves. The NHS says limping is often from a sprain, strain, blister, cut, bruise or broken bone, but not to self-diagnose: a limp with no obvious cause should always be checked by a GP, as it could be a sign of something serious. Its list of other causes includes irritable hip, a slipped upper femoral epiphysis (a problem at the top of the thigh bone), juvenile arthritis, Perthes' disease and, rarely, a cancer such as leukaemia, sarcoma or lymphoma (a lump on the leg, weight loss or pain at night).
A child with a fever who has a swollen limb or joint, won't use a limb or won't put weight on it may have a bone or joint infection, NICE (the National Institute for Health and Care Excellence) says, and UK orthopaedic standards say a joint infection needs draining, ideally within 24 hours. That's why a doctor examines a limping child before anything else, and why Köhler's disease is a diagnosis made after these checks.
Sources 1, 2, 3, 4
What Köhler's disease is
The navicular is a small, boat-shaped bone on the inner side of the midfoot, in front of the ankle. In Köhler's disease it temporarily loses part of its blood supply, so it flattens and looks dense and broken up on an X-ray, then rebuilds itself. A Canadian children's hospital explains that this causes pain and swelling of the foot. Alban Köhler first described it in 1908.
The navicular is the last bone of the foot to start turning from cartilage into bone, at about 18 to 24 months in girls and 30 to 36 months in boys, and that late start is thought to make it more vulnerable to pressure from walking and running. A classic study of 52 normal children's feet and 62 children with Köhler's disease concluded that pressure on a late-forming navicular explains the irregular bone, and that further pressure brings on the symptoms. It gets better on its own.
Sources 5, 6, 7, 8
Who gets itEmerging evidence
Young children: it's seen between about 2 and 10, most often at 4 to 7, though one medical manual gives 3 to 5. Boys get it 4 to 5 times as often as girls. It's usually in one foot; both feet are affected in about 1 in 4 or 5 children.
Sources 8, 6, 5, 9
What you might notice
Pain on the top and inner side of the midfoot, worse with walking and better with rest; mild swelling; tenderness over the navicular; and a limp, sometimes walking on the outer edge of the foot. In some children the limp is the only sign at first, which can delay the diagnosis.
Sources 5, 6, 9, 10
How it's diagnosed, and what the X-ray does and doesn't meanEmerging evidence
A doctor examines the foot and arranges an X-ray. The navicular looks flattened and dense, and later in pieces, and an X-ray of the other foot can help in doubtful cases. A magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) scan is occasionally used to rule out an infection or a tumour.
The X-ray needs the examination to go with it. Irregular bone formation is part of how some normal naviculars form, and in 2,166 children's foot X-rays taken for any reason, 3% showed something unusual about the navicular, and about 80% of those findings were judged incidental, not the cause of the child's symptoms. The X-ray also takes 1 to 2 years to look normal again after the bone has healed, so it can't tell you when your child is ready to play.
Sources 5, 6, 9, 11, 7, 12
How it usually goesEmerging evidence
It gets better with time. In 12 children reviewed 33 years later, all were free of symptoms with no deformity or arthritis, and the bone took an average of 8 months to rebuild, whatever the treatment. In 14 children (16 feet) reviewed after about 31 years, 12 feet had a good result and 2 a fair one because of other foot problems, and the authors expect a normal foot in adulthood. In 20 children, every navicular rebuilt and function was excellent.
Estimates of how long it takes differ: a Canadian children's hospital gives 6 months to 3 to 4 years for full healing, and a medical manual says it rarely lasts more than 2 years. These are small, old studies and broad estimates, but they agree on the ending.
Sources 13, 14, 11, 5, 9
Look-alikes
An accessory navicular, an extra bone at the same spot, usually starts hurting at 10 to 15 and leaves a bump. Sever's disease hurts at the heel, and Iselin's disease on the outer edge of the foot, in older, active children. Each has its own guide. A broken bone, an infection, juvenile arthritis and the hip conditions are why the limp is checked first: if you think a foot bone or a toe is broken, the NHS says not to treat it yourself but to contact NHS 111, and to take a child who has hurt or broken a toe to A&E.
In adults, a similar-looking navicular problem, Müller-Weiss disease, is a different condition, mostly in women, and a specialist manages it.
Sources 1, 15, 16, 17