What it is and how it happensStrong evidence
The LCL, also called the fibular collateral ligament, is a cord on the outer side of the knee. It runs from the outer bump of the thigh bone to the head of the fibula, the thin bone on the outer side of the shin. It's the main structure that stops the knee bowing outwards, especially between straight and 30 degrees of bend, and it helps stop the shin twisting outwards when the knee is bent. It's tight when the knee is straight and slackens as the knee bends.
It's injured by a force that pushes the knee outwards (such as a blow to the inside of the knee), by a twist, or by the knee bending backwards (over-straightening). At one German sports injury centre, LCL injuries were linked with tennis and gymnastics. In Brazilian jiu-jitsu, a bent knee forced outwards tore part of the LCL in 7 of 27 acute knee injuries in one series, and heel hooks in climbing have done it in case reports. Of 55 elite athletes with isolated LCL injuries in a London series, 44 were footballers and 10 rugby players.
Sources 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6
How common it is, and the corner it belongs toEmerging evidence
LCL injuries are uncommon. Of 7,769 sports knee injuries at one centre, they made up 1.1%, against 7.9% for the MCL and 20.3% for the ACL (anterior cruciate ligament). The American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons (AAOS) puts them at under 2% of knee injuries.
With the popliteus tendon and the popliteofibular ligament, the LCL forms the posterolateral corner (PLC), the back outer corner of the knee. Injuries there usually come with other damage: in 331 acute knee injuries that bled into the joint, PLC injuries were found in 9.1%, and 26 of those 30 came with other ligament tears. In cadaver knees, an untreated PLC injury raised the load on a reconstructed ACL, and reviews stress finding these injuries early, because a missed one can leave the knee unstable or make a cruciate reconstruction fail.
Sources 4, 2, 7, 8, 9, 10
How it feels and how it's recognisedEmerging evidence
Pain and tenderness on the outer knee, swelling over the injured spot, stiffness, and sometimes a pop or a feeling that the knee will give way. Some injuries seem minor at first: 5 of the 55 elite athletes first sought help 33 to 103 days later, after the knee gave way again or swelled.
A clinician pushes the knee outwards with it straight and bent to about 30 degrees, and compares it with the other knee. Opening only at 30 degrees points to the LCL; opening with the knee straight, or extra outward twisting of the shin, points to a wider PLC or cruciate injury. X-rays don't show the ligament, but they show a flake of bone pulled off with it, usually from the fibula, and tenderness on the head of the fibula after an injury is one of the five findings of the Ottawa knee rule, which doctors use to decide on an X-ray. In children and teenagers, the growth plate can be injured instead of the ligament.
Sources 2, 1, 3, 11, 12, 13
The gradesStrong evidence
Clinicians grade an LCL sprain by how far the outer knee opens when it's pushed, compared with the other knee.
- Grade 1 (mild): the ligament is stretched and the knee is stable, with up to about 5 millimetres (mm) of extra opening.
- Grade 2 (moderate): a partial tear; the ligament is loose, with about 5 to 10 mm of extra opening.
- Grade 3 (severe): a complete tear, or the ligament pulled off the bone; the knee is unstable, with more than 10 mm.
Sources 2, 3
What an MRI does and doesn't tell youEmerging evidence
An MRI (magnetic resonance imaging) scan shows the ligaments, cartilage and menisci, but its grade can mislead. In 55 elite athletes, MRI and examination grades agreed poorly: 27 (49%) had a complete tear on MRI, but only 1 had grade 3 looseness on examination. The authors suggest the sheath around the ligament and the structures next to it can hold the knee stable.
So a complete tear on a scan isn't, by itself, a reason for surgery. How loose the knee is on examination, and what else is injured, matter more.
Sources 3, 2
How it usually goesEmerging evidence
Isolated grade 1 and 2 injuries do well without surgery. All 55 elite athletes in one series went back to their previous level, at a median of 76 days (between 0 and 422 days), 93% were still playing 2 years later, and none had grade 2 or 3 looseness at review. In 9 National Football League (NFL) players with complete isolated tears on MRI, the 5 treated without surgery missed about 2 weeks, against 14.5 weeks after surgical repair, and all 9 played the following season.
Complete tears with a loose knee behaved differently in an older series. In 23 people treated without surgery and followed for about 8 years, grade 2 sprains did well, but grade 3 sprains often left lasting looseness, weakness, a failing ACL and arthritis; in the same author's X-ray study, arthritis developed in 5 of 10 complete tears against none of 11 partial ones. Single case reports describe teenagers with complete isolated tears back in sport at about 3 and 4 months without surgery.
Sources 3, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18
How it differs from other outer and inner knee pain
IT band (iliotibial band) syndrome comes on without an injury and builds during a run or ride. An MCL sprain hurts on the inner side after a blow to the outside of the knee. A meniscus tear hurts on the joint line and may catch or lock, and a pop with swelling of the whole knee within hours points to an ACL injury. Each has its own guide.
Sources 2, 1