What happens in a hyperextension injury
The knee is forced past straight: a planted foot as the body falls backwards, a blow to the front of the shin with the leg straight, a tackle, or a landing on straight legs. The front of the shin bone and the end of the thigh bone are squashed together, leaving matching ('kissing') bone bruises that show on MRI (magnetic resonance imaging), while the structures at the back of the knee are stretched. The list below shows what can be hurt.
- The PCL: the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons (AAOS) lists a twisting or hyperextension injury among its causes.
- The ACL, less often. In a review of 30 studies of bone bruises after ACL tears, the bruise pattern that suggests hyperextension was uncommon (3.5% to 6.8% of shin bone bruises); most ACL tears come from changing direction, stopping or landing badly.
- The back of the joint capsule: hyperextension is one of the main ways it tears, and those tears are easily missed on examination and MRI.
- The outer back corner of the knee (the posterolateral corner), from a force backwards and outwards. In 39 people with a severe corner injury and a torn cruciate ligament, 44% had an injury to the nerve that lifts the foot, all with matching bone bruises at the front inner side of the knee. On its own, a lateral collateral ligament (LCL) tear is uncommon, under 2% of knee injuries.
- Both cruciate ligaments, when the knee dislocates: one type of dislocation usually comes from extreme hyperextension.
Sources 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9
The emergency: a dislocated kneeEmerging evidence
After a knee dislocation, the artery behind the knee is injured in about 18% of cases on average, and 27% of people with an injured artery still had a pulse that could be felt at first. A nerve is injured in about 19%, mostly the one that lifts the foot. That's why a deformed knee, a cold, pale or numb foot, or a knee that felt as if it came out after a high-energy injury is a 999 call, even if a pulse can be felt.
Sources 9, 10
Sprains and bone bruises
An injury can range from a mild sprain to torn ligaments, which is why the warning signs matter. At the milder end, pain at the back of the knee and a pinch at the front are typical. The NHS says most sprains feel better after 2 weeks, that strenuous exercise such as running should wait up to 8 weeks, and that severe sprains can take months to get back to normal.
Bone bruises seen on MRI fade over months: those with a tear of the inner knee ligament (the medial collateral ligament, or MCL) may heal in 2 to 4 months, those with an ACL tear more slowly (a median of 3 months on the thigh bone and 6 on the shin bone), and 95% of bruises without damage to the bone surface resolve. Their long-term course is poorly studied.
Sources 10, 2
X-ray or not: the Ottawa knee ruleStrong evidence
Clinicians use the Ottawa knee rule: an X-ray is needed if you are 55 or over, the bony bump on the outer side just below the knee (the head of the fibula) is tender, only the kneecap is tender, you can't bend the knee to 90°, or you couldn't take 4 steps both straight after the injury and in the clinic. It identified every fracture when it was tested, and 98.5% across 6 studies of 4,249 adults.
Ligaments and bone bruises don't show on X-rays. MRI shows them when the examination suggests a scan is needed.
Sources 11, 12, 13
When an injury is missedEmerging evidence
In 12 young people (median age 18.5) who still had pain and couldn't get back to sport after a hyperextension, earlier MRI scans hadn't explained it. Examining the knee near straight showed extra backward bending and a backward sag of the shin, from an injury to one bundle of the PCL. Pain, or a feeling that the knee goes back too far, weeks after a hyperextension is a reason for a specialist examination rather than another scan (our reading).
Source 14
Knees that bend back naturally
Most knees straighten slightly past 0°, and doctors call a knee that bends back further genu recurvatum. In a US reference study of 674 healthy people aged 2 to 69, knees went past straight by 5.4° on average in girls and 1.6° in boys aged 2 to 8, falling to 1.2° in women and 0.5° in men aged 45 to 69. Girls and women were more mobile in nearly every joint, and range fell with age.
A knee that bends back more than 10° scores a point on the 9-point Beighton score for general hypermobility (5 or more suggests it in adults, 6 in children before puberty, 4 over 50). It's common in dancers: 72% of 85 elite Australian dancers met the cut-off. Children become less bendy as they grow: in 126 children aged 6 to 11 followed for 2 years, the share with the highest scores fell from 25% to 6%. The NHS says joint hypermobility syndrome mostly affects children and young people and often gets better with age.
Sources 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20
After a stroke: a different problem
A knee that snaps back while walking after a stroke is common (reported in 19.5% to 65% of people who walk unaided) and comes from weakness, tight calf and thigh muscles and poor joint sense. It's managed with braces, electrical stimulation and walking practice, led by a physiotherapist or orthotist. Cerebral palsy and polio can do the same. This guide's plan isn't for it.
Source 21