What a sit-up asks of the neck, and what no study has countedEmerging evidence
Lying on your back, your head is a weight the neck has to lift and hold before your trunk even starts to curl. In a traditional curl-up with the arms by the sides, the sternocleidomastoid (the strap-like muscle from behind the ear to the breastbone) worked at 32% of its maximum in 13 healthy men and at about 54% in 12 healthy adults. Laced hands used to pull bend the neck further, which is why a review of 87 abdominal muscle studies lists "do not pull with the hands behind the head" among its safety rules, though no study has measured it.
No study counts neck pain or injury from sit-ups or crunches. In a trial of 1,141 soldiers, sit-up training caused no more injuries than core stabilisation work, but neck injuries weren't reported separately. NHS inform names muscle strain and "repeating the same strained movements in work, sports and hobbies" among the causes of neck problems, and says they "are rarely caused by any serious disease or damage". So the map on this page is built from what each cause is known to do; that the neck hurts when its muscles, or a neck that was already sore, are asked to do more than they are used to is our reading, not a counted fact.
Sources 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6
Where it hurts, and what it often isEmerging evidence
The front and sides of the neck, both sides, during the reps or a day or two after: the neck muscles holding the head up, or soreness in them after a new or bigger session. The back of the neck or the base of the skull: often pulling on the head. A sudden catch on one side, then stiff to turn: a strain or ordinary neck pain, which NHS inform says usually improves within weeks.
A neck that was already sore or stiff can flare with sit-ups. Neck arthritis (cervical spondylosis) "is a normal part of ageing and many people do not have any symptoms", the NHS says, and people with long-lasting neck pain tend to use the deep neck muscles less and the superficial ones more in a nod test (10 people against 10).
Some front-of-neck pain isn't the sit-ups: swollen glands, a sore throat and an inflamed thyroid (tender, with a sore throat or a flu-like illness) have their own signs and need checking. A tear of the sternocleidomastoid itself is rare, known from case reports after exercise or lifting weights, and a sudden painful swelling needs blood vessel causes ruled out first.
Sources 4, 5, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12
Rare but serious: an artery, a bleed, meningitis and the spinal cordStrong evidence
A torn neck artery affects about 2.6 people per 100,000 a year, and 80% have head or neck pain; 40.5% of 966 people with one had a minor knock or strain in the month before, most of them mild. A bleed on the brain brings a sudden, extremely painful headache, and the NHS says it may be more likely when "lifting something heavy"; in 250 people, vigorous exercise carried a relative risk of 2.4. Meningitis brings a stiff neck with a fever, a very painful headache or a rash that doesn't fade. No study links any of these to sit-ups, and they are rare, but they are why a sudden, severe headache or neck pain unlike any before is a 999 call.
The NHS sends new problems walking, loss of bladder or bowel control or a sudden loss of coordination to 999, as signs of pressure on the spinal cord, and a headache triggered or made worse by exercising to an urgent GP appointment or NHS 111. Muscle breakdown after a big, unaccustomed session, such as hundreds of sit-ups in a challenge, is rare and needs a same-day check.
Sources 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 7, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22
What a scan shows, and when it mattersStrong evidence
Ordinary neck pain is recognised from the story and a simple examination; neither the NHS nor NHS inform suggests a scan for it, and Arthritis UK says "it's unlikely that you'll need any special tests". The US physical therapy guideline asks clinicians to follow imaging guidelines. Tests matter after a fall or accident, for arm weakness or numbness that is getting worse, for a sudden severe headache and for a fever with a stiff neck.
Scans mislead when used alone: 87.6% of 1,211 people without symptoms had bulging discs on MRI (magnetic resonance imaging), including 73.3% of men and 78.0% of women in their 20s; disc changes rose with age to 86% to 89% of discs over 60 in 497 people; and across 17 studies (5,059 people), 64.5% of people without symptoms had changes at several discs.
Sources 5, 4, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27
How it usually goesEmerging evidence
The neck working hard during a set eases as soon as you stop, and soreness after a new session fades within about a week. For a strain or ordinary neck pain, the NHS says "Most neck pain only lasts a few weeks", and NHS inform says "You should see the biggest change in your symptoms within the first couple of weeks. Most problems should have improved within 8 weeks."
Neck pain often comes back: between half and three quarters of people with neck pain report it again 1 to 5 years later, and feelings and coping were the strongest predictors of how it went. No one can promise a date.
Sources 5, 4, 28