The best trial: holding strength roseEmerging evidence
In Spain, 60 women aged 60 to 80 (49 finished) did Pilates, resistance training or no training, twice a week for 18 weeks. Strength holding the hip extended rose 35.5% with Pilates and 21.4% with resistance training, and only that measure beat no training. On a machine that measures strength through movement (isokinetic), every hip measure rose 27% to 34% within the resistance group and some within the Pilates group, but the groups didn't differ. Both groups improved everyday function tests and lean mass. There were no adverse events.
Sources 3, 26
Other small trialsEmerging evidence
Twelve weeks of mat Pilates, made harder every 4 weeks, raised machine-measured hip strength in 14 women aged about 62, with no separate control group. In 48 active women aged about 65, mat and apparatus Pilates both improved leg and arm strength tests over 8 weeks against controls, with no difference between them. Two non-randomised studies of middle-aged women found more leg strength, about 13.5% in one.
Sources 27, 28, 29, 30
About as good as other exerciseEmerging evidence
Against doing nothing, Pilates improved strength in people aged 60 and over across 39 studies (a moderate effect, moderate certainty). Against other exercise, it built no more strength across 11 trials (very low to low certainty) or 24 trials in people over 60.
Sources 4, 5, 31
No glute growth shownEmerging evidence
In 12 inactive women, 36 weeks of studio Pilates twice a week didn't change the size of gluteus maximus, medius or minimus on magnetic resonance imaging (MRI). There was no comparison group. Our Pilates for glutes guide covers growing them.
Source 24
Hip range: small gainsEmerging evidence
In 32 women over 60, 3 months of Pilates improved trunk and hip bending, and static stretching improved them too; only trunk extension differed between the groups. In 20 older adults with no control group, 10 weeks of Pilates raised hip bending by 10% to 16%. Across 12 studies of adult women, Pilates improved the sit-and-reach test, which measures the hamstrings and lower back more than the hip; an earlier review of 9 trials found no clear flexibility gain.
Sources 32, 33, 34, 35
Strength through the range adds rangeEmerging evidence
Strength training improved range of movement about as much as stretching across 11 trials, and across 55 studies, except when it used body weight alone. So the side kick, bridges and 90/90 lifts count, and making them harder helps.
Sources 6, 7
Control on one leg: mixedMixed evidence
Eight weeks of mat Pilates let 85% of 40 healthy adults pass a pressure-cuff test of lower back control, against none of the controls, but that's a tummy test, not a one-leg task. In 36 young adults whose knee drifted inwards on a single-leg squat, Pilates and neuromuscular training both improved the knee angle (12 people per group). In 34 novice runners, 12 weeks of home Pilates didn't significantly change the knee drifting in while running. In 34 teenagers with kneecap pain, Pilates-based core work added to physiotherapy raised side hip strength more than physiotherapy alone, in a small trial.
Sources 36, 37, 38, 39
Mat, reformer or wallEmerging evidence
Mat and apparatus Pilates improved strength and flexibility tests equally in older women. In 30 amateur footballers, reformer Pilates beat mat on agility and a hop test. On the Cadillac, where the spring is attached changes how the load peaks through a hip extension. You don't need a reformer; springs, bands and one-leg versions all make the work harder.
Sources 28, 40, 41
What we couldn't find
Our searches found no Pilates trial of hip strength in healthy adults under 60 with a proper control group, none that measured glute growth against a control group, and no study of muscle activity in the side kick, side-lying series or leg circle. A trial of clinical Pilates in hip osteoarthritis and two studies of the bridge on the mat and reformer have finished but posted no results.
Sources 42, 43, 44, 45