The angle and your arms set the difficultyEmerging evidence
On a variable-angle Roman chair in 10 adults, lower-back muscle activity rose by up to 104% from the easiest to the hardest of 24 set-ups as the chair became more level and the hands moved further overhead. The angle mattered more than the hands.
Source 2
The 45-degree bench works the glutes and hamstrings hardEmerging evidence
In 15 resistance-trained women lifting a weight they could manage 6 times, the 45-degree back extension worked the glutes 140% harder than a seated back-extension machine (the Romanian deadlift 94% harder), no differently from the Romanian deadlift overall but 74% harder in the top half. It worked the outer hamstring 71% harder than the Romanian deadlift and 174% harder than the machine. Lower-back activity was similar in all three.
Source 1
Small changes shift the workEmerging evidence
In 12 adults, turning the hips in raised lower-back muscle activity by 18%, and keeping a stronger curve in the lower back raised it by 25%, with no change in the glutes or hamstrings. In 18 male athletes, bending the knees to a right angle raised lat, lower-back and glute activity, and hands behind the head raised the lower trapezius.
Sources 8, 12
No study of the rounded-back version
We found no study that compared a rounded-back back extension with a flat-back one, so the popular "glute-focused" version (feet turned out, upper back rounded, a shorter range) is untested.
Training builds endurance; lower-back strength is less clearEmerging evidence
In a trial of 36 adults, 1 set of 15 to 25 on a variable-angle Roman chair three times a week raised back-muscle endurance by 42% in 8 weeks, but not lower-back strength measured on a machine. One set of 8 to 20 once a week for 12 weeks didn't raise it either, in 15 adults. Supervised back and core exercise twice a week for 24 weeks raised back endurance by 12% in 96 firefighters.
Sources 3, 13, 14
Exercise raises back-muscle endurance in back painEmerging evidence
In 8 trials of 508 people with non-specific low back pain, exercise raised lower-back muscle endurance more than passive or active comparison treatments.
Source 15
Back and hip strength training for chronic back painMixed evidence
Across 8 small trials of 408 people, strength training for the back of the body eased chronic low back pain a little more than general exercise or walking (a standardised difference of 0.61, whose confidence interval reached zero) and eased disability a little (0.53), with no more side effects; 12 to 16 weeks did better than 6 to 8. The trials used varied exercises, and in a pilot trial of 30 men, adding machine back extensions or deadlifts to core work gave no extra benefit.
Sources 4, 5
Does a strong back prevent back pain?Mixed evidence
In 928 adults followed for a year, men with better back-muscle endurance had less first-time back trouble. But a review of 12 cohort studies of 5,459 people found back strength and endurance didn't predict who developed back pain.
Sources 16, 17
The spine is loaded, more in some versions than othersEmerging evidence
In 13 young men, exercises that actively lifted the trunk loaded the spine most of four back-extensor exercises, and extending one leg with the spine held still loaded it least. In 8 adults, back extensions on a gym ball loaded the spine less, with no more muscle activity than on a mat.
Sources 18, 19
The reverse hyperextension: two studies disagreeMixed evidence
In 20 adults, the reverse hyperextension moved the hips through more range (77 against 65 degrees) with less lower-back bending (20 against 31 degrees), but put a higher load on the lower back and drew less total glute and hamstring activity than the back extension, with equal back-muscle activity. In 10 adults, it drew 34 to 71% higher peak activity in all three muscles.
Sources 9, 10
Osteoporosis: back-strengthening is recommendedStrong evidence
The UK consensus on exercise for osteoporosis recommends exercises that strengthen the back, done 3 to 5 times and held 3 to 5 seconds, at least twice a week, and avoiding or modifying sustained, repeated or end-range bending forward. After a spinal fracture, it advises gentle back exercises daily.
Source 6
Trials in osteoporosis and a rounded upper backEmerging evidence
In 80 women with osteoporosis, a home exercise lifting the upper trunk face down to straight raised back strength by 26% against 11%, and quality of life by 7% against none, in 4 months. In 50 women, those who had done 2 years of progressive back-strengthening had fewer spinal fractures 10 years after starting (1.6% of vertebrae against 4.3%). In 99 adults aged 60 or over, spine-strengthening and posture training three times a week for 6 months reduced the curve of a rounded upper back by 3 degrees.
Sources 7, 20, 21