What a plank asks of the shoulder, and what no study has countedEmerging evidence
In a plank you hang your trunk between your feet and your arms, so the shoulders hold up a big share of your weight while staying still. In 8 men, the hands took 66.4% of body weight at the start of a normal push-up, which is the high plank position, and 52.9% from the knees. In 18 students, shoulder muscle activity rose with each step of more weight through the arms, staying at only 2% to 10% of maximum on all fours, and the infraspinatus, one of the rotator cuff muscles, worked hardest. The serratus anterior, which holds the shoulder blade against the ribs, works hardest in the push-up plus (30 people; a review of 30 studies agrees).
Older studies don't help much: the classic serratus study gave no plank figures, early-rehab shoulder blade exercises worked the serratus and lower trapezius at 15% to 30% of maximum, and the best-known study of trunk muscles in planks measured no shoulder muscle except the latissimus dorsi. No study has counted shoulder pain from planks. One case report describes a shoulder blade that stuck out after planks done badly (a long thoracic nerve palsy), with the nerve recovering about a month after stopping them. So this map is built from what each condition does, muscle studies in healthy people and NHS pages (our reading).
Sources 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8
High, forearm and side planksEmerging evidence
In 21 healthy men doing 10 plank variations, the high (straight-arm) plank worked the lower trapezius and triceps harder than the forearm plank, and taking away a point of support (a hand or a foot) raised shoulder and shoulder blade muscle work. A high plank with a toe touch markedly raised upper trapezius work, while the side plank, bird dog and shoulder taps kept it below the serratus and lower trapezius. The authors suggest plank variations may be used in shoulder rehabilitation. Nobody has compared the two planks for shoulder pain, so which hurts less differs from person to person (our reading).
In a side plank the bottom shoulder works hard: in 24 active women, the deltoids tired as fast as the side trunk muscles, and both predicted how long they held. Researchers say there is no data on the load on the supporting shoulder in a standard side bridge. The only shoulder force figures come from a straight-arm side plank with a twist in 10 people, where forces approached half of body weight; no one has measured a forearm side plank.
Sources 9, 10, 11, 12
Where it hurts sorts the causesEmerging evidence
The NHS lists pain that's often worse while using the arm under tendonitis, bursitis and impingement, pain on top where the collarbone meets the shoulder, and tingling, numbness, weakness or clicking under an unstable shoulder, sometimes with very flexible joints. In shoulders that slip backwards, push-ups are a known trigger.
A change in how the shoulder blade moves (dyskinesis) is present in a high proportion of shoulder injuries, a consensus says, but its role is unclear; in 419 symptom-free athletes it went with more shoulder pain later (35% against 25%). A true nerve palsy that makes the blade stick out is rare (15 in 7,000 patients in one nerve-testing laboratory, 1 in 38,500 in another clinic), weight training is among its reported causes, and it is often first mistaken for a rotator cuff or instability problem. The NHS says see a GP for pins and needles or a cold arm with neck pain.
Sources 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19
Chest pain comes firstStrong evidence
A plank raises your heart rate and blood pressure. The NHS says most chest pain is not a sign of anything serious, and describes a chest strain as pain that starts after a chest injury or chest exercise and eases when you rest the muscle. It says call 999 for chest pain that feels tight or like squeezing, or that spreads to your arms, neck or jaw. If you're unsure which it is, the warning signs come first.
Sources 20, 21
What a scan or test shows, and when it mattersEmerging evidence
Not at first, for an ache without warning signs: the NHS says a health professional examines the shoulder first and might send you for tests such as an X-ray. A shoulder that came out of place usually has an X-ray in hospital. A shoulder blade that suddenly sticks out with new weakness needs a GP, and nerve tests may be needed to find which nerve is affected; scans of the shoulder joint can mislead in winging, which is often first put down to other problems.
Sources 13, 22, 16, 17
How it usually goesEmerging evidence
No study follows shoulder pain from planks. The NHS says self-care usually needs about 2 weeks before shoulder pain starts to ease, that it can take 6 months or longer to recover, and suggests shoulder exercises for 6 to 8 weeks to stop pain returning. After a dislocation, recovery usually takes 6 to 12 weeks, and up to 16 weeks or longer for some sports. Most serratus palsies recover within 24 months, though after surgery-related palsy 25 of 26 people still had symptoms years later. In shoulders that slip without an injury, scores of about 80% of a normal shoulder are seen around 12 weeks into a structured programme. No one can promise a date.
Sources 13, 22, 16, 23, 18