What nobody has countedEmerging evidence
No survey of hikers gives a share for hip pain. On the Appalachian Trail, 36% of 280 long-distance hikers reported acute joint pain, and 61% of 1,295 reported a muscle or joint complaint, 28% from overuse; on the John Muir Trail, pack strap pain was the third commonest complaint (46%). Across 7 studies of 17,757 injured hikers, the legs were the commonest injured site in every study, and most injuries were minor; in 5,665 hikers who fell in the Austrian Alps, 37.8% of non-fatal injuries were to the ankle and foot.
So the map on this page is built from lab studies of slopes, packs and poles, mostly in healthy young adults, military load carriage, studies of the conditions, and NHS, NHS inform and NICE pages, not from counts of hikers, and it says so.
Sources 1, 2, 3, 4, 5
Uphill is hip workEmerging evidence
In 20 adults, the hip's pushing work more than doubled from level ground to a 9 degree slope, and on an 18 degree ramp it rose almost six times. In 9 adults on steep slopes, the extra effort going up came mainly from the hip extensors (the buttock and back of the hip), and in 11 men the hip bent further at each step as the slope steepened. Uphill walking raised the modelled forces through every leg joint as the slope steepened in 18 men.
So climbs ask the buttock muscles to push and the front of the hip to bend further, step after step. A front of the hip or a buttock that aches on a long climb is usually muscles and tendons working harder than usual (our reading).
Sources 6, 7, 8, 9, 10
Downhill is mostly the knee, a little more for the hipEmerging evidence
In 12 people, the turning forces at the hip were only slightly larger walking downhill, while the knee's were much higher. Modelling in 18 men found downhill walking raised the force through the hip and the work of the big buttock muscle, while the knee took a larger share of the braking. The only measured hip forces come from 6 people with instrumented hip replacements: the peak was 300% of body weight walking on a flat treadmill, 319% on a 10% climb and 335% on a 10% descent.
Descents matter for another reason: 75.3% of hikers who fell in the Austrian Alps fell on the way down.
Sources 11, 10, 12, 7, 13, 5
The pack, the hip belt and long daysEmerging evidence
In a computer model of 6 Marines carrying 38 kg, a pack raised the forces through the hip joint, and they were similar whether the weight hung from the shoulders or the hip belt. In 9 men carrying 15 to 25 kg, a tighter hip belt didn't change how they walked. In 15 women hikers carrying up to 40% of their body weight over 8 km, the way they walked changed to absorb the load and became less stable at 30% and 40%; the authors suggested a 30% limit, a ceiling rather than a target. In soldiers, hip belts take pressure off the shoulders and add comfort, and load carriage injuries cluster in the legs.
A long day with a hip belt can also squeeze the skin nerve of the outer thigh: 10 of 280 Appalachian Trail hikers had it, and 98% of the numbness and tingling on that trail had settled at follow-up. The nerve only carries feeling, so there is no weakness.
Sources 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21
How the causes are told apartEmerging evidence
A pulling ache at the front of the hip on climbs, as you lift the knee, is usually the hip flexors; a consensus lists hip flexor-related groin pain among the defined causes of groin pain in athletes. A deep pinch in the groin on high steps in a younger active adult can be hip impingement, which needs symptoms, examination signs and imaging together. A deep groin, buttock or front-of-thigh ache from mid-life, stiff after sitting and for less than 30 minutes in the morning, is often hip arthritis, which NICE diagnoses without imaging; hip joint pain was felt in the buttock in 71% of 51 people and never in the lower back.
The bony point on the outside of the hip, sore after long days, on sloping paths and to lie on at night, is usually the gluteal tendons, with pain on standing on one leg, stairs and walking; squeezing the tendons and the knee drifting across are key factors. A burning or numb patch on the outer thigh under the belt is a squeezed skin nerve. The inner thigh after a slip is usually an adductor strain, and a lump in the groin can be a hernia; a femoral hernia is a small lump at the top of the thigh, in the groin. Thighs and buttocks sore for a few days after a big descent are muscle soreness; a short downhill walk a week before cut the damage by 47% to 64% in young men.
Groin or front-of-hip pain that built up after far more walking than usual, hurting with every step or at night, can be a stress fracture of the hip: rare, but a high index of suspicion is needed, a normal X-ray doesn't rule it out, and in military recruits pelvic stress fractures were far commoner in women. A calf, thigh or buttock ache that goes within minutes of standing still can be narrowed arteries. A swollen, throbbing calf or thigh after a long day or a journey of more than 4 hours can be a blood clot. A child or teenager with hip, thigh or knee pain or a limp needs checking: the NHS says a limp with no obvious cause should always be checked by a GP, and a slipped growth plate at the hip usually happens between 11 and 17.
Sources 22, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27, 21, 28, 29, 30, 31, 32, 33, 34, 35, 36, 37, 38
When a scan helps, and how it usually goesStrong evidence
Not at first for most: NICE diagnoses hip arthritis without imaging, gluteal tendon pain is diagnosed by examination, and impingement needs symptoms and examination first, with imaging to confirm. A suspected stress fracture needs imaging the same day, and an MRI (magnetic resonance imaging) scan if the X-ray is normal. A fall with severe pain needs an X-ray, and a groin lump needs a GP to examine it.
The NHS asks for a GP visit if hip pain hasn't improved after 2 weeks at home, and NHS inform says most new hip problems begin to settle within 6 weeks. Muscle soreness after a descent fades within days. Outer hip pain is slower: in the LEAP trial, education and exercise was still ahead of an injection at a year (51 of 65 against 36 of 63 rated a success). For hip-related pain in active adults, exercise should last at least 3 months. Belt numbness almost always settles. No one can promise a date.
Sources 24, 26, 23, 31, 39, 40, 41, 29, 42, 43, 20